开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

wangtao19910225 · 2021年09月02日

如下

NO.PZ2018091702000015

问题如下:

Herman, 48 years old, is a successful musician.He is a passive investor who is careful in the investment. Herman overestimates his risk tolerance while shows a low risk tolerance, he exhibits framing bias, availability bias and conservative bias.

Fabian is a businessman and 46 years old. He has independent idea and investment with significant financial leverage. His investment portfolio is managed by himself, and almost 80% stocks are invested in financial sector. Fabian is confident about his investment and exhibits a high level of risk tolerance. He exhibits loss aversion bias, overconfidence bias and illusion of control bias.

Darcy is 65 years old, he has significant wealth because of a successful family business. Darcy is very cautious about the future and worries about his assets. He has low risk tolerance but will take advices from experts. Darcy exhibits status quo bias, regret-aversion bias and endowment bias.

All three clients above answered a risk tolerance questionnaire. Regarding their different characteristics, whose questionnaire works best?

选项:

A.

Fabian.

B.

Herman.

C.

Darcy.

解释:

B is correct.

考点:调查问卷在行为金融学中的问题

解析emotional bias的客户比调查问卷对有cognitive bias的客户更有效所以这道题的考点是区分哪些bias属于cognitive哪些属于emotionalHerman的三个偏差都是认知偏差所以他的调查问卷最有效

 framing bias 难道不是容易被问问题的方式所误导,为什么通过提问的方式还效果最好呢


1 个答案

王琛_品职助教 · 2021年09月02日

嗨,爱思考的PZer你好:


1

这道题考查的知识点是:传统风险容忍度调查问卷的局限性 "Limitations of Traditional Risk Tolerance Questionnaires"

原理是这样的:

从行为金融学的角度来看,与个人投资者相比,风险容忍度问卷作为机构投资者的诊断工具可能效果更好

这种差异是因为,机构投资者熟悉均值-方差优化并思考风险问题。对他们来说,风险分析是一个认知的过程 "cognitive process"

个人投资者更可能对风险是从感觉上去理解,对他们来说,风险分析是一个情感过程 "emotional process"

因此,风险容忍度调查表可能会对有 emotional bias 的人不管用 "risk tolerance questionnaires may fail emotionally biased individuals."

2

理解了原理,这道题其实更本质考查的是行为偏差的分类

如果考试碰到同样题型,解题思路也是:只需要对正文背景中提到的行为偏差,准确判断出是所属 cognitive 还是 emotional 即可,不用深究具体某个偏差哈

----------------------------------------------
加油吧,让我们一起遇见更好的自己!