开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)｜3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

返回

hbc0728 · 2021年08月07日

请问老师A为什么不对？

  1. FRM II
  2. Market Risk Measurement And Management

NO.PZ2020033001000002

问题如下：

Assuming that Company A's profit and loss satisfy a normal distribution, its annual average value is $30 million and its standard deviation is $10 million. Which of the following statements about the calculation and interpretation of the 95% VaR value is correct?

选项：

A.

5% probability that the company will lose at least $13.5 million.

B.

5% probability that the company will earn at least $13.5 million.

C.

95% probability that the company will lose at least $13.5 million.

D.

95% probability that the company will earn at least $13.5 million.

解释：

D is correct.

考点：Parametric Estimation Approaches

解析：95%的VaR=30-1.65*10=13.5m

这道题的计算结果非常特殊，VaR值计算结果为正，无需取绝对值，也就是说有95%的概率盈利至少为13.5million。

请问老师A为什么不对？

添加评论
mumu榕 · 2022年01月28日

如果A的描述换成5%的最大盈利是13.5m，是正确的吗

2 个答案

品职答疑小助手雍 · 2022年01月28日

不正确，最大盈利就应该把收益从高往低排，那5%最大的盈利肯定是比均值高的。

13.5这个说的是最差的5%里面，最好的情况是盈利13.5。

理解了这个意思之后，怎么描述是语言问题，不是知识点计算的问题。

品职答疑小助手雍 · 2021年08月07日

嗨，从没放弃的小努力你好：


因为95%的分位点是正值，所以D没错哈。

用A的说法应该是loss at least -13.5M。 既然是收益只能说成是负的loss。

----------------------------------------------
虽然现在很辛苦，但努力过的感觉真的很好，加油！

  • 2

    回答

  • 1

    关注

  • 655

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2020033001000002 问题如下 Assuming thCompany A's profit anloss satisfy a normstribution, its annuaverage value is $30 million anits stanrviation is $10 million. Whiof the following statements about the calculation aninterpretation of the 95% Vvalue is correct? A.5% probability ththe company will lose least $13.5 million. B.5% probability ththe company will earn least $13.5 million. C.95% probability ththe company will lose least $13.5 million. 95% probability ththe company will earn least $13.5 million. is correct. 考点Parametric Estimation Approaches 解析95%的VaR=30-1.65*10=13.5m这道题的计算结果非常特殊，VaR值计算结果为正，无需取绝对值，也就是说有95%的概率盈利至少为13.5million。 那如果VAR是负就代表5%的概率损失超过数值，如果是正的就是95%的概率收益超过数值。应用到本题，不应该是5%的概率，损失超过13.55么？请问哪里理解不正确？

2024-10-08 13:50 2 · 回答

公式显示不正确 这个公式不应该用-U+ZV吗

2024-08-26 14:37 1 · 回答

公式显示不正确 这个公式不应该用-U+ZV吗

2024-08-26 14:37 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2020033001000002 问题如下 Assuming thCompany A's profit anloss satisfy a normstribution, its annuaverage value is $30 million anits stanrviation is $10 million. Whiof the following statements about the calculation aninterpretation of the 95% Vvalue is correct? A.5% probability ththe company will lose least $13.5 million. B.5% probability ththe company will earn least $13.5 million. C.95% probability ththe company will lose least $13.5 million. 95% probability ththe company will earn least $13.5 million. is correct. 考点Parametric Estimation Approaches 解析95%的VaR=30-1.65*10=13.5m这道题的计算结果非常特殊，VaR值计算结果为正，无需取绝对值，也就是说有95%的概率盈利至少为13.5million。 老师好，如题

2023-12-29 22:02 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2020033001000002问题如下 Assuming thCompany A's profit anloss satisfy a normstribution, its annuaverage value is $30 million anits stanrviation is $10 million. Whiof the following statements about the calculation aninterpretation of the 95% Vvalue is correct? A.5% probability ththe company will lose least $13.5 million.B.5% probability ththe company will earn least $13.5 million.C.95% probability ththe company will lose least $13.5 million.95% probability ththe company will earn least $13.5 million. is correct. 考点Parametric Estimation Approaches 解析95%的VaR=30-1.65*10=13.5m这道题的计算结果非常特殊，VaR值计算结果为正，无需取绝对值，也就是说有95%的概率盈利至少为13.5million。 比如，如果计算VaR，按照理论是否永远可以用U--ZQ。另外，收益和损失分布如何区别？如何判断是收益分布还是损失分布？分布不同是否计算公式不同？这个问题从一级就没有弄清楚。非常困惑。烦请解答，谢谢。

2023-07-20 16:51 1 · 回答