开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)｜3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

返回

大太阳 · 2021年05月26日

老师这个思路有什么错吗？

  1. CFA II
  2. Corporate Issuers

NO.PZ2018101501000067

问题如下：

Company M now is all equity-financed and the cost of capital is 12%. EBIT of Company M is $0.6 million. Management is considering changing the capital structure so they intend to issue 2 million new debt to repurchase outstanding shares. The tax rate is 30% and the before-tax cost of debt is 8%. What’s the cost of equity after changing the capital structure according to the MM`s proposition with tax?

选项：

A.

17.60%

B.

15.73%

C.

14.67%

解释：

C is correct.

考点：Capital Structure Theory: with tax

解析：VU=EBIT(1−T)r0=0.6∗(1−30%)12%V_U=\frac{EBIT(1-T)}{r_0}=\frac{0.6\ast(1-30\%)}{12\%} = $3.5 million

VL = VU + T*D = 3.5 + 30%*2 = $4.1 million

E = VL –D = 4.1 – 2 = $2.1 million

根据公式re=r0+(r0−rd)∗(1−T)∗DEr_e=r_0+(r_0-r_d)\ast(1-T)\ast\frac DE

                = 12% + (12% -8%) * (1-30%) * (2/2.1) = 14.67%

在原来全投资的情况下Equity=0.6/12%=5, 债券回购股票2million，这样Equity就是3million，而不是答案的2.1million，想知道思路哪里错了？

添加评论
1 个答案

王琛_品职助教 · 2021年05月26日

嗨，努力学习的PZer你好：


同学的思路中，有两个地方错了哈

1）在原来全投资假设时，Vu，即 Equity 的价值，并不是同学计算的 5，而是解析中的 3.5。同学使用的计算公式中，分子要乘以税率的。虽然没有债务，但是有税。

2）同学后半部分的思路，是想用计算出来的 3.5 m，直接减去发债回购的 2 m，得到 1.5 m.

但是还没完，因为对于股东来说，发债要交利息，而利息是税前列支，有税盾作用，相当于因为缴税而产生的好处是 DxT，即 2 x 0.3 = 0.6，所以最后，Equity 为 1.5 + 0.6 = 2.1

思路，也请参考：https://class.pzacademy.com/qa/61193

----------------------------------------------
就算太阳没有迎着我们而来，我们正在朝着它而去，加油！

  • 1

    回答

  • 0

    关注

  • 428

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2018101501000067 Company M now is all equity-financeanthe cost of capitis 12%. EBIT of Company M is $0.6 million. Management is consiring changing the capitstructure so they intento issue 2 million new to repurchase outstanng shares. The trate is 30% anthe before-tcost of is 8%. What’s the cost of equity after changing the capitstructure accorng to the MM`s proposition with tax? 17.60% 15.73% 14.67% C is correct. 考点CapitStructure Theory: with t解析 VU=EBIT(1−T)r0=0.6∗(1−30%)12%V_U=\frac{EBIT(1-T)}{r_0}=\frac{0.6\ast(1-30\%)}{12\%}VU​=r0​EBIT(1−T)​=12%0.6∗(1−30%)​ = $3.5 million VL = VU + T*= 3.5 + 30%*2 = $4.1 million E = VL –= 4.1 – 2 = $2.1 million 根据公式 re=r0+(r0−r∗(1−T)∗r_e=r_0+(r_0-r_\ast(1-T)\ast\frre​=r0​+(r0​−r)∗(1−T)∗E                 = 12% + (12% -8%) * (1-30%) * (2/2.1) = 14.67% 这道题是要把Proposal1和2的公式结合起来用吗 两个proposal不是相互独立吗？

2021-07-15 10:23 1 · 回答

Company M now is all equity-financeanthe cost of capitis 12%. EBIT of Company M is $0.6 million. Management is consiring changing the capitstructure so they intento issue 2 million new to repurchase outstanng shares. The trate is 30% anthe before-tcost of is 8%. What’s the cost of equity after changing the capitstructure accorng to the MM`s proposition with tax? 17.60% 15.73% 14.67% C is correct. 考点CapitStructure Theory: with t解析 VU=EBIT(1−T)r0=0.6∗(1−30%)12%V_U=\frac{EBIT(1-T)}{r_0}=\frac{0.6\ast(1-30\%)}{12\%}VU​=r0​EBIT(1−T)​=12%0.6∗(1−30%)​ = $3.5 million VL = VU + T*= 3.5 + 30%*2 = $4.1 million E = VL –= 4.1 – 2 = $2.1 million 根据公式 re=r0+(r0−r∗(1−T)∗r_e=r_0+(r_0-r_\ast(1-T)\ast\frre​=r0​+(r0​−r)∗(1−T)∗E                 = 12% + (12% -8%) * (1-30%) * (2/2.1) = 14.67% 老师，如果已知中没有repurchase outstanng shares这个条件，对计算过程有影响吗？

2020-09-15 14:36 1 · 回答

Company M now is all equity-financeanthe cost of capitis 12%. EBIT of Company M is $0.6 million. Management is consiring changing the capitstructure so they intento issue 2 million new to repurchase outstanng shares. The trate is 30% anthe before-tcost of is 8%. What’s the cost of equity after changing the capitstructure accorng to the MM`s proposition with tax? 17.60% 15.73% 14.67% C is correct. 考点CapitStructure Theory: with t解析 VU=EBIT(1−T)r0=0.6∗(1−30%)12%V_U=\frac{EBIT(1-T)}{r_0}=\frac{0.6\ast(1-30\%)}{12\%}VU​=r0​EBIT(1−T)​=12%0.6∗(1−30%)​ = $3.5 million VL = VU + T*= 3.5 + 30%*2 = $4.1 million E = VL –= 4.1 – 2 = $2.1 million 根据公式 re=r0+(r0−r∗(1−T)∗r_e=r_0+(r_0-r_\ast(1-T)\ast\frre​=r0​+(r0​−r)∗(1−T)∗E                 = 12% + (12% -8%) * (1-30%) * (2/2.1) = 14.67% 如果8%是after tcost of bt，该如何做？是要先用8%除以1-t，求出税前bt成本再带入公式么？

2020-02-17 21:49 1 · 回答

请问为什么equity valve随着bt增加而减少了？没有杠杆的firm value不应该是equity value吗

2019-03-21 19:50 1 · 回答