开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

金融民工阿聪 · 2021年01月24日

A为什么错呢

问题如下:

Which of the following statements about VAR estimation methods is wrong?

选项:

A.

The delta-normal VAR method is more reliable for portfolios that implement portfolio insurance through dynamic hedging than for portfolios that implement portfolio insurance through the purchase of put options.

B.

The full-valuation VAR method based on historical data is more reliable for large portfolios that contain significant option-like investments than the delta-normal VAR method.

C.

The delta-normal VAR method can understate the true VAR for stock portfolios when the distribution of the return of the stocks has high kurtosis.

D.

Full-valuation VAR methods based on historical data take into account nonlinear relationships between risk factors and security prices.

解释:

Full-valuation methods are more precise for portfolios with options, so answers B and D are correct. The delta-normal VAR understates the risk when distributions have fat tails, so answer C is correct. Answer A is indeed wrong. The delta-normal method will be poor for outright positions in options, or their dynamic replication.

A为什么错呢,A里面说动态对冲比买put更好,怎么判断呢,delta normal对于两种都差,那怎么对比谁更差?

2 个答案

品职答疑小助手雍 · 2021年01月27日

不是*confidence level而是乘以confidence leve的对应值(比如,2.33和1.65这些)。在var mapping里学的哦

品职答疑小助手雍 · 2021年01月25日

嗨,从没放弃的小努力你好:


a说的是delta normal更适用于做动态对冲的portfolio相对于使用put option做保障的portfolio。动态对冲因为是动态的,所以整个P的价值一直在变化,你用delta-normal算var的公式不是delta*V*confidence level对应值么?这个V和delta都在变,所以公式就没法用了。当然put option那个也不好用,这样其实俩策略都不好用,不能比较。

既然不能比较,A就不能理直气壮的说谁好谁坏~


-------------------------------
虽然现在很辛苦,但努力过的感觉真的很好,加油!


金融民工阿聪 · 2021年01月27日

delta*V*confidence level这个公式在哪里有的,这个怎么感觉没啥印象

  • 2

    回答
  • 1

    关注
  • 581

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2016070202000018 问题如下 Whiof the following statements about Vestimation metho is wrong? A.The lta-normVmethois more reliable for portfolios thimplement portfolio insuranthrough namic heing thfor portfolios thimplement portfolio insuranthrough the purchase of put options. B.The full-valuation Vmethobaseon historicta is more reliable for large portfolios thcontain significant option-like investments ththe lta-normVmetho C.The lta-normVmethocunrstate the true Vfor stoportfolios when the stribution of the return of the stocks hhigh kurtosis. Full-valuation Vmetho baseon historicta take into account nonlinerelationships between risk factors ansecurity prices. Full-valuation metho are more precise for portfolios with options, so answers B anare correct. The lta-normVunrstates the risk when stributions have ftails, so answer C is correct. Answer A is inewrong. The lta-normmethowill poor for outright positions in options, or their namic replication. 请问每种metho用于什么样的portfolio这个内容在哪里?

2023-01-30 12:04 2 · 回答

NO.PZ2016070202000018 The full-valuation Vmethobaseon historicta is more reliable for large portfolios thcontain significant option-like investments ththe lta-normVmetho The lta-normVmethocunrstate the true Vfor stoportfolios when the stribution of the return of the stocks hhigh kurtosis. Full-valuation Vmetho baseon historicta take into account nonlinerelationships between risk factors ansecurity prices. Full-valuation metho are more precise for portfolios with options, so answers B anare correct. The lta-normVunrstates the risk when stributions have ftails, so answer C is correct. Answer A is inewrong. The lta-normmethowill poor for outright positions in options, or their namic replication. 老师解析中的outright position是什么意思

2022-09-29 17:59 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2016070202000018 老师能一下这道题吗?四个几乎都不太理解

2022-03-10 17:47 2 · 回答

NO.PZ2016070202000018 No.PZ2016070202000017 老师可以讲解lta normv中怎么理解B和the money 和 即将到期 的影响是什么 C的含义是什么

2022-02-20 20:47 1 · 回答