开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

•西• · 2020年11月13日

问一道题:NO.PZ2018062009000028 [ CFA II ]

问题如下:

Smith, an analyst in a local asset management firm, covers Brazil equities and directs brokerage to Brazil who pays Smith’s briefing trip to Brazil through a soft dollar arrangement. Smith is not sure that the broker’s execution is competitive and he decides to use commission dollars to pay for his hotel expenses. Does Smith violate the Code and Standards?

选项:

A.

Yes, Smith violates Standard III(A) by not knowing whether the commissions charged by Brazil are reasonable and using commission dollars to pay hotel expenses.

B.

Yes, Smith violates Standard III(A) only by using commission dollars to pay hotel expenses.

C.

No, Smith doesn't violate Code and Standards.

解释:

A is correct.

Smith violates Standard III(A) by not exercising her duty of loyalty to her clients. He should have determined whether the commissions charged by Brazil are reasonable in relation to the benefit of the research provided by the trip. The hotel expenses should not be paid for with commission dollars, which is client's asset.

这道题错误的地方在于不能用佣金支付吗
1 个答案

Debrah_品职答疑助手 · 2020年11月13日

嗨,努力学习的PZer你好:


这道题目错误的地方有两点:

一是根据原文,Smith is not sure that the broker’s execution is competitive。这里没有履行对客户忠诚的义务。确定execution是否有竞争力、佣金是否合理是Smith的本职工作。

二是decides to use commission dollars to pay for his hotel expenses. 这里实质就是soft dollar。基金经理为了帮客户投资会选择外部机构,外部机构会返还给基金经理一些额外的“好处”,这些“好处”本质上是客户购买的,这些额外的服务可以称为Soft dollar。这些Soft dollar本质上是客户买的,是从客户Commission fee里扣掉的,所以属于客户的资产、只能用于客户的投资。在这里用于支付酒店费用,与客户无关,所以违反。


-------------------------------
就算太阳没有迎着我们而来,我们正在朝着它而去,加油!


  • 1

    回答
  • 0

    关注
  • 381

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2018062009000028 问题如下 Smith, analyst in a locasset management firm, covers Brazil equities anrects brokerage to Brazil who pays Smith’s briefing trip to Brazil through a soft llarrangement. Smith is not sure ththe broker’s execution is competitive anhe cis to use commission llars to pfor his hotel expenses. es Smith violate the Co anStanr? A.Yes, Smith violates StanrIII(not knowing whether the commissions chargeBrazil are reasonable anusing commission llars to photel expenses. B.Yes, Smith violates StanrIII(only using commission llars to photel expenses. C.No, Smith esn't violate Co anStanr. A is correct.Smith violates StanrIII(not exercising her ty of loyalty to her clients. He shoulhave terminewhether the commissions chargeBrazil are reasonable in relation to the benefit of the researprovithe trip. The hotel expenses shoulnot paifor with commission llars, whiis client's asset.Smith因为没有对客户旅行忠诚的责任而违反了准则III(A)。他应该确定Brazil提供的旅行是否直接有利于帮助客户做投资决策。佣金不可以用来付旅行的费用,因为佣金依然属于客户的钱。 老师,soft llar只能用于为客户做投资决策的research,意思是题目中说的“巴西负责人通过软美元安排支付史密斯前往巴西的旅行费用”,这个去做research路上的旅行费用也能用soft llar吗?那去做research的时候吃的饭也能用soft llar吗?

2024-08-23 19:24 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2018062009000028问题如下 Smith, analyst in a locasset management firm, covers Brazil equities anrects brokerage to Brazil who pays Smith’s briefing trip to Brazil through a soft llarrangement. Smith is not sure ththe broker’s execution is competitive anhe cis to use commission llars to pfor his hotel expenses. es Smith violate the Co anStanr?A.Yes, Smith violates StanrIII(not knowing whether the commissions chargeBrazil are reasonable anusing commission llars to photel expenses.B.Yes, Smith violates StanrIII(only using commission llars to photel expenses.C.No, Smith esn't violate Co anStanr. A is correct.Smith violates StanrIII(not exercising her ty of loyalty to her clients. He shoulhave terminewhether the commissions chargeBrazil are reasonable in relation to the benefit of the researprovithe trip. The hotel expenses shoulnot paifor with commission llars, whiis client's asset.Smith因为没有对客户旅行忠诚的责任而违反了准则III(A)。他应该确定Brazil提供的旅行是否直接有利于帮助客户做投资决策。佣金不可以用来付旅行的费用,因为佣金依然属于客户的钱。 客户是巴西,经纪也是巴西?题干什么意思?

2024-03-27 23:15 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2018062009000028 问题如下 Smith, analyst in a locasset management firm, covers Brazil equities anrects brokerage to Brazil who pays Smith’s briefing trip to Brazil through a soft llarrangement. Smith is not sure ththe broker’s execution is competitive anhe cis to use commission llars to pfor his hotel expenses. es Smith violate the Co anStanr? A.Yes, Smith violates StanrIII(not knowing whether the commissions chargeBrazil are reasonable anusing commission llars to photel expenses. B.Yes, Smith violates StanrIII(only using commission llars to photel expenses. C.No, Smith esn't violate Co anStanr. A is correct.Smith violates StanrIII(not exercising her ty of loyalty to her clients. He shoulhave terminewhether the commissions chargeBrazil are reasonable in relation to the benefit of the researprovithe trip. The hotel expenses shoulnot paifor with commission llars, whiis client's asset.Smith因为没有对客户旅行忠诚的责任而违反了准则III(A)。他应该确定Brazil提供的旅行是否直接有利于帮助客户做投资决策。佣金不可以用来付旅行的费用,因为佣金依然属于客户的钱。 “covers Brazil equities anrects brokerage to Brazil who pays Smith’s briefing trip to Brazil through a soft llarrangement“ 这句话想表达什么意思?因为严格上是病句啊

2022-11-07 23:52 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2018062009000028 问题如下 Smith, analyst in a locasset management firm, covers Brazil equities anrects brokerage to Brazil who pays Smith’s briefing trip to Brazil through a soft llarrangement. Smith is not sure ththe broker’s execution is competitive anhe cis to use commission llars to pfor his hotel expenses. es Smith violate the Co anStanr? A.Yes, Smith violates StanrIII(not knowing whether the commissions chargeBrazil are reasonable anusing commission llars to photel expenses. B.Yes, Smith violates StanrIII(only using commission llars to photel expenses. C.No, Smith esn't violate Co anStanr. A is correct.Smith violates StanrIII(not exercising her ty of loyalty to her clients. He shoulhave terminewhether the commissions chargeBrazil are reasonable in relation to the benefit of the researprovithe trip. The hotel expenses shoulnot paifor with commission llars, whiis client's asset.Smith因为没有对客户旅行忠诚的责任而违反了准则III(A)。他应该确定Brazil提供的旅行是否直接有利于帮助客户做投资决策。佣金不可以用来付旅行的费用,因为佣金依然属于客户的钱。 RT,谢谢

2022-09-29 09:15 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2018062009000028 问题如下 Smith, analyst in a locasset management firm, covers Brazil equities anrects brokerage to Brazil who pays Smith’s briefing trip to Brazil through a soft llarrangement. Smith is not sure ththe broker’s execution is competitive anhe cis to use commission llars to pfor his hotel expenses. es Smith violate the Co anStanr? A.Yes, Smith violates StanrIII(not knowing whether the commissions chargeBrazil are reasonable anusing commission llars to photel expenses. B.Yes, Smith violates StanrIII(only using commission llars to photel expenses. C.No, Smith esn't violate Co anStanr. A is correct.Smith violates StanrIII(not exercising her ty of loyalty to her clients. He shoulhave terminewhether the commissions chargeBrazil are reasonable in relation to the benefit of the researprovithe trip. The hotel expenses shoulnot paifor with commission llars, whiis client's asset.Smith因为没有对客户旅行忠诚的责任而违反了准则III(A)。他应该确定Brazil提供的旅行是否直接有利于帮助客户做投资决策。佣金不可以用来付旅行的费用,因为佣金依然属于客户的钱。 答案“佣金不可以用来付旅行的费用,因为佣金依然属于客户的钱。”,那么B也是正确啊。

2022-06-27 22:25 1 · 回答