开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

natalie2003 · 2020年09月30日

问一道题:NO.PZ2015121810000024 [ CFA II ]

问题如下:

Nick Young is concerned that Goudon Partners, one of his money managers, overestimates its expected active return because Goudon overstates its strategy breadth. Young makes two notes about his concern:

Note 1: Although Goudon claims that the number of independent asset decisions is high because it uses 200 stocks, many of these stocks cluster in industries where the same general analysis applies to several stocks.

Note 2: Goudon claims that each stock is independent and evaluated each month, or 12 times per year. These analyses are not independent because some of their strategies, such as favoring a particular industry or favoring value stocks, persist beyond one month. For example, a strategy of favoring low-P/E stocks will persist for several months and the investment decisions are not independent.

If his judgments are correct, are Young’s notes about the overstatement of breadth correct?

选项:

A.

Only Note 1 is correct.

B.

Only Note 2 is correct.

C.

Both Notes 1 and 2 are correct.

解释:

C is correct.

If the decisions about each of the 200 stocks are not independent, and if the decisions about a stock from one month to the next are not independent, then Goudon Partners is overstating its estimates of its breadth and its expected active returns.

考点:breadth

解析: Note 1 正确,200只股票中有cluster-扎堆现象,扎堆在某些行业中并且使用相同的分析方法。因此尽管声称200只股票都是独立预测的,但采用相同的分析方法说明扎推行业的股票预测之间的相关性系数比较高,说明BR是被高估的。

Note 2正确,尽管一个股票一年看似预测12次,但是某些策略(例如投资低P/E股票)会持续好几个月,那么这几个月的预测就不是独立的。因此BR被高估。

老师您好,“is high”是不是存在一些歧议?我因为这个描述把它判错了,毕竟“高估”和“高”还是有点区别吧……
1 个答案

星星_品职助教 · 2020年09月30日

同学你好,

这里面的Goudon claims that the number of independent asset decisions “is high”because it uses 200 stocks. 指得是BR=200这个次数是非常高的。这里面is high就是“很高”的意思,没有“高估”的意思

但由于实际独立的次数不足200,所以按照200算出来的值会比实际的值要高,所以算出来的这个错误的值是被高估了的。是这个意思。

  • 1

    回答
  • 0

    关注
  • 874

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2015121810000024 问题如下 NiYoung is concernethGoun Partners, one of his money managers, overestimates its expecteactive return because Goun overstates its strategy breah. Young makes two notes about his concern:Note 1: Although Goun claims ththe number of inpennt asset cisions is high because it uses 200 stocks, many of these stocks cluster in instries where the same generanalysis applies to severstocks.Note 2: Goun claims theastois inpennt anevaluateeamonth, or 12 times per year. These analyses are not inpennt because some of their strategies, sufavoring a particulinstry or favoring value stocks, persist beyonone month. For example, a strategy of favoring low-P/E stocks will persist for severmonths anthe investment cisions are not inpennt. If his juments are correct, are Young’s notes about the overstatement of breah correct? A.Only Note 1 is correct. B.Only Note 2 is correct. C.Both Notes 1 an2 are correct. C is correct.If the cisions about eaof the 200 stocks are not inpennt, anif the cisions about a stofrom one month to the next are not inpennt, then Goun Partners is overstating its estimates of its breah anits expecteactive returns. 考点breah解析 Note 1 正确,200只股票中有cluster-扎堆现象,扎堆在某些行业中并且使用相同的分析方法。因此尽管声称200只股票都是独立预测的,但采用相同的分析方法说明扎推行业的股票预测之间的相关性系数比较高,说明BR是被高估的。Note 2正确,尽管一个股票一年看似预测12次,但是某些策略(例如投资低P/E股票)会持续好几个月,那么这几个月的预测就不是独立的。因此BR被高估。 对note 2的回答难以理解。难道某个策略持续好几个月就代表不独立吗? 课件或者书本有相关的内容说到这个意思?

2023-06-18 22:42 1 · 回答

请问这题的note 1怎么理解?为什么是对的

2018-12-15 13:34 1 · 回答

    这道题目中note2描述的perist beyounone month是什么意思?是说明导致实际预测的次数多了还是少了

2018-11-20 14:12 1 · 回答

    老师您好,这题A为什么是对的呢?麻烦您一下,谢谢了~

2017-01-30 16:48 4 · 回答