开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

Danielle靓靓 · 2018年10月26日

问一道题:NO.PZ2017092702000133 [ CFA I ]

问题如下图:

选项:

A.

B.

C.

提问:老师,我觉得abc都是对的,请问为何选c。请指教,谢谢。 解释:

1 个答案
已采纳答案

菲菲_品职助教 · 2018年10月26日

同学你好,A选项说P值用来当做假设检验判断的一个证据比临界值点精确度要低,这个描述是欠妥的。因为我们可以直接通过比较P值和α,就可以直接判断假设检验的结果,这个其实是更精确的一个判断依据。

B选项说,P值是用来拒绝原假设最大的一个显著性水平。这句话说反了。P-value应该是最小的能拒绝原假设的显著性水平。(这也是原版书和讲义的原话)

我们怎么来理解这句话呢?因为P值越小越拒绝原假设。当p值小于α时,我们拒绝原假设。就如何老师在基础班中讲的一样,举个例子,已知p值=6%,问α怎么设定才能拒绝原假设。因为当p值小于α时,我们拒绝原假设,所以α至少要大于等于6%,我们才能拒绝原假设,也就可以理解成P-value是最小的能拒绝原假设的显著性水平。

  • 1

    回答
  • 2

    关注
  • 506

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2017092702000133 问题如下 Whiof the following statements is correwith respeto the p-value? A.It is a less precise measure of test evinthrejection points. B.It is the largest level of significanwhithe null hypothesis is rejecte C.It ccomparerectly with the level of significanin reaching test conclusions. C is correct.When rectly comparing the p-value with the level of significance, it cusealternative to using rejection points to reaconclusions on hypothesis tests. If the p-value is smaller ththe specifielevel of significance, the null hypothesis is rejecte Otherwise, the null hypothesis is not rejecte对于一个分布而言,每个概率面积在横轴上都有一个对应点,例如significanlevel α对应的分位点就是临界值criticvalue(假设正态分布下α=95%,双尾检验,则右尾就会对应criticvalue=1.96)。而p-value也是一个概率面积,对应的点就是计算出来的检验统计量的那个点。所以当p-value<α时,就等价于检验统计量>criticvalue,也就是拒绝原假设。 能方便一下- 为何是smallest 而不是 largest 吗? 以下为我的理解 - p-value 是一个概率, i.e. 如果 p-value 为 0.06 - 则我们可以理解为有 6% 的可能性 the null hypothesis 为 true (base on the available samples). 而 level of significan只是一个 pre-finethresholof rejecting null hypothesis - i.e. if p-value = thresholthen we conclu there is statisticevinto support null hypothesis being true, otherwise, we rejenull hypothesis. e.g. when p-value 0.05 level of significan= 0.05 -- 则我们可以rejenull. Regaress p-value = 0.04, 0.03 etc -- 我们都可以rejenull, 那么level of significan岂不是一个upper boun 而p-value 也可以理解为 一个大值 where we coulrejea null? 请问我的理解错在了哪里? 谢谢

2024-03-25 10:15 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2017092702000133问题如下 Whiof the following statements is correwith respeto the p-value?A.It is a less precise measure of test evinthrejection points. B.It is the largest level of significanwhithe null hypothesis is rejecte C.It ccomparerectly with the level of significanin reaching test conclusions. C is correct.When rectly comparing the p-value with the level of significance, it cusealternative to using rejection points to reaconclusions on hypothesis tests. If the p-value is smaller ththe specifielevel of significance, the null hypothesis is rejecte Otherwise, the null hypothesis is not rejecte对于一个分布而言,每个概率面积在横轴上都有一个对应点,例如significanlevel α对应的分位点就是临界值criticvalue(假设正态分布下α=95%,双尾检验,则右尾就会对应criticvalue=1.96)。而p-value也是一个概率面积,对应的点就是计算出来的检验统计量的那个点。所以当p-value<α时,就等价于检验统计量>criticvalue,也就是拒绝原假设。 请问老师,a错在哪里?

2023-12-31 18:19 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2017092702000133问题如下Whiof the following statements is correwith respeto the p-value?A.It is a less precise measure of test evinthrejection points. B.It is the largest level of significanwhithe null hypothesis is rejecte C.It ccomparerectly with the level of significanin reaching test conclusions. C is correct.When rectly comparing the p-value with the level of significance, it cusealternative to using rejection points to reaconclusions on hypothesis tests. If the p-value is smaller ththe specifielevel of significance, the null hypothesis is rejecte Otherwise, the null hypothesis is not rejecte对于一个分布而言,每个概率面积在横轴上都有一个对应点,例如significanlevel α对应的分位点就是临界值criticvalue(假设正态分布下α=95%,双尾检验,则右尾就会对应criticvalue=1.96)。而p-value也是一个概率面积,对应的点就是计算出来的检验统计量的那个点。所以当p-value<α时,就等价于检验统计量>criticvalue,也就是拒绝原假设。 p value和test statistic 的关系?

2023-05-28 17:09 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2017092702000133 问题如下 Whiof the following statements is correwith respeto the p-value? A.It is a less precise measure of test evinthrejection points. B.It is the largest level of significanwhithe null hypothesis is rejecte C.It ccomparerectly with the level of significanin reaching test conclusions. C is correct.When rectly comparing the p-value with the level of significance, it cusealternative to using rejection points to reaconclusions on hypothesis tests. If the p-value is smaller ththe specifielevel of significance, the null hypothesis is rejecte Otherwise, the null hypothesis is not rejecte对于一个分布而言,每个概率面积在横轴上都有一个对应点,例如significanlevel α对应的分位点就是临界值criticvalue(假设正态分布下α=95%,双尾检验,则右尾就会对应criticvalue=1.96)。而p-value也是一个概率面积,对应的点就是计算出来的检验统计量的那个点。所以当p-value<α时,就等价于检验统计量>criticvalue,也就是拒绝原假设。 请老师指导,B哪里错了?

2022-12-29 21:05 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2017092702000133 问题如下 Whiof the following statements is correwith respeto the p-value? A.It is a less precise measure of test evinthrejection points. B.It is the largest level of significanwhithe null hypothesis is rejecte C.It ccomparerectly with the level of significanin reaching test conclusions. C is correct.When rectly comparing the p-value with the level of significance, it cusealternative to using rejection points to reaconclusions on hypothesis tests. If the p-value is smaller ththe specifielevel of significance, the null hypothesis is rejecte Otherwise, the null hypothesis is not rejecte对于一个分布而言,每个概率面积在横轴上都有一个对应点,例如significanlevel α对应的分位点就是临界值criticvalue(假设正态分布下α=95%,双尾检验,则右尾就会对应criticvalue=1.96)。而p-value也是一个概率面积,对应的点就是计算出来的检验统计量的那个点。所以当p-value<α时,就等价于检验统计量>criticvalue,也就是拒绝原假设。 能不能翻译一下每个?不怎么了解

2022-11-28 10:42 1 · 回答