开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)｜3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

返回

cy g. · 2024年08月15日

如题

  1. CFA III
  2. Equity

NO.PZ2019012201000063

问题如下：

Which fund in Exhibit 1 most likely follows a bottom-up approach?

选项：

A.

Fund 1

B.

Fund 2

C.

Fund 3

解释：

Bottom-up managers evaluate the risk and return characteristics of individual securities and build portfolios based on stock-specific forecasts; Fund 3 follows this exact approach. Example views of bottom-up managers include expecting one auto company to outperform another, expecting a pharmaceutical company to outperform an auto company, and expecting a technology company to outperform a pharmaceutical company. Both bottom-up and top-down managers can be either diversified or concentrated in terms of securities.

为什么fund 2 不是bottom up。 题干不是也说这个fund是针对每个个股么。

添加评论
1 个答案

笛子_品职助教 · 2024年08月15日

嗨，爱思考的PZer你好：


为什么fund 2 不是bottom up。 题干不是也说这个fund是针对每个个股么。


Hello，亲爱的同学。fund 2 虽然关注个股成长，但是它不属于bottom up。


fund 2里，基金经理摆出了一个观点，然后按照这个观点来配置股票，所有的股票配置，都不是基于股票自身微观特征，而只是为这个观点服务。这里隐含了一个逻辑，股票不是基于自身，而是基于观点，而bottom up 必须基于股票自身，而不能基于其他因素，这就否定掉了bottom up，用排除法就只有Top down。


具体可以原版书黄色部分，对风格有先验的观点，是top down。虽然本题没有阐述，基金经理主观认为，growth风格要比value风格好，是基于什么原因，但是结合原版书内容，原版书认为，会产生这种先验性风格判断观点的因素，这可能是基于宏观因素，比如油价上涨，现金跑赢股票，或者基于现金与股票的资产配置。


认为某个风格（例如growth）强于另一个风格（例如value），属于top down。这个知识点，就用这道题来补充吧。

----------------------------------------------
就算太阳没有迎着我们而来，我们正在朝着它而去，加油！

  • 1

    回答

  • 0

    关注

  • 128

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2019012201000063 问题如下 Whifunin Exhibit 1most likely follows a bottom-up approach? A.Fun1 B.Fun2 C.Fun3 Bottom-up managersevaluate the risk anreturn characteristiof invisecurities anbuilortfolios baseon stock-specific forecasts; Fun3 follows this exactapproach. Example views of bottom-up managers inclu expecting one autocompany to outperform another, expecting a pharmaceuticcompany to outperformauto company, anexpecting a technology company to outperform apharmaceuticcompany. Both bottom-up antop-wn managers ceither versifier concentratein terms of securities. 题干里给出了这个highly versifieportfolio.所以我果断的就把C排除了。老师，实际来说，是否是highly versifieportfolio不决定自上而下还是自下而上是吧，highly versifieportfolio.是决定系统还是人脑判断呗？

2024-04-29 12:54 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2019012201000063 问题如下 Whifunin Exhibit 1most likely follows a bottom-up approach? A.Fun1 B.Fun2 C.Fun3 Bottom-up managersevaluate the risk anreturn characteristiof invisecurities anbuilortfolios baseon stock-specific forecasts; Fun3 follows this exactapproach. Example views of bottom-up managers inclu expecting one autocompany to outperform another, expecting a pharmaceuticcompany to outperformauto company, anexpecting a technology company to outperform apharmaceuticcompany. Both bottom-up antop-wn managers ceither versifier concentratein terms of securities. 请问2为什么不对？还有fun描述里的最后一句话的意思是？

2023-08-25 15:12 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2019012201000063 问题如下 Whifunin Exhibit 1most likely follows a bottom-up approach? A.Fun1 B.Fun2 C.Fun3 Bottom-up managersevaluate the risk anreturn characteristiof invisecurities anbuilortfolios baseon stock-specific forecasts; Fun3 follows this exactapproach. Example views of bottom-up managers inclu expecting one autocompany to outperform another, expecting a pharmaceuticcompany to outperformauto company, anexpecting a technology company to outperform apharmaceuticcompany. Both bottom-up antop-wn managers ceither versifier concentratein terms of securities. 三个都帮忙解读一下，谢谢

2022-11-20 20:21 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2019012201000063问题如下 Whifunin Exhibit 1most likely follows a bottom-up approach? A.Fun1B.Fun2C.Fun3 Bottom-up managersevaluate the risk anreturn characteristiof invisecurities anbuilortfolios baseon stock-specific forecasts; Fun3 follows this exactapproach. Example views of bottom-up managers inclu expecting one autocompany to outperform another, expecting a pharmaceuticcompany to outperformauto company, anexpecting a technology company to outperform apharmaceuticcompany. Both bottom-up antop-wn managers ceither versifier concentratein terms of securities. 它不是也关注个股的成长性嘛？

2022-10-06 13:24 1 · 回答