开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

雨洁🦄 · 2024年08月06日

什么情况下选择最优化的方法呢

NO.PZ2023010903000028

问题如下:

Välimaa next considers the transition of the Fund’s portfolio holdings, which have a total market value of EUR 150 million. She is constructing the portfolio using individual equities and considers the following methods: full replication, stratified sampling, and optimization. The benchmark for the portfolio is the FTSE Eurotop 100 Index, which is based on market capitalization and consists of 100 of the largest publicly traded European companies. The investment committee prefers not to use sophisticated algorithms that are difficult to understand.

Determine, from the three methods that Välimaa is considering, the most appropriate method for constructing the equity portfolio. Justify your response.

解释:

Answer

Full replication is suitable.

The value of the Fund’s equity portfolio is EUR 150 million and is large enough to follow a full replication approach of the FTSE Eurotop 100 Index. The constituents of this index are the top 100 large capitalization European equities, which are likely liquid and available for trading. The full replication approach requires owning each of the securities in the benchmark portfolio. Tracking error is likely to remain low since the number of constituents in this index is not large.

Stratified sampling is less appropriate since it does not track the index as closely as full replication, which would result in higher tracking error relative to full replication. The board prefers not to use sophisticated algorithms that are difficult to understand, making the optimization approach less appropriate.

关于最优化方法的选项

2 个答案

笛子_品职助教 · 2024年08月12日

嗨,从没放弃的小努力你好:


Hello,亲爱的同学~


这里有个知识点:

在适合使用full replication的时候,full replication最好。

在不适合使用full replicaitoni的时候,可以使用stratified sampling与optimation。


如果比较stratified sampling与optimation,optimation的trakcing error更低。

具体用stratified sampling还是optimation,要看题目的具体描述。


结合本题,本题适合使用full replication,因此stratified sampling与optimation都可以排除了。

----------------------------------------------
努力的时光都是限量版,加油!

笛子_品职助教 · 2024年08月07日

嗨,努力学习的PZer你好:


Hello,亲爱的同学~

在不适合使用full replication的时候,例如index是流动性很差的中小盘股的时候,用最优化较好。

本题,index是流动性很好的大盘股,用full replication较好。

----------------------------------------------
加油吧,让我们一起遇见更好的自己!

雨洁🦄 · 2024年08月12日

那为什么不用stratified sampling呢

  • 2

    回答
  • 1

    关注
  • 93

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2023010903000028 问题如下 Välimnext consirs the transition of the Funs portfolio holngs, whihave a totmarket value of EUR 150 million. She is constructing the portfolio using inviequities anconsirs the following metho: full replication, stratifiesampling, anoptimization. The benchmark for the portfolio is the FTSE Eurotop 100 Inx, whiis baseon market capitalization anconsists of 100 of the largest publicly traEuropecompanies. The investment committee prefers not to use sophisticatealgorithms thare fficult to unrstantermine, from the three metho thVälimis consiring, the most appropriate methofor constructing the equity portfolio. Justify your response. AnswerFull replication is suitable.The value of the Funs equity portfolio is EUR 150 million anis large enough to follow a full replication approaof the FTSE Eurotop 100 Inx. The constituents of this inx are the top 100 large capitalization Europeequities, whiare likely liquianavailable for trang. The full replication approarequires owning eaof the securities in the benchmark portfolio. Tracking error is likely to remain low sinthe number of constituents in this inx is not large.Stratifiesampling is less appropriate sinit es not trathe inx closely full replication, whiwoulresult in higher tracking error relative to full replication. The boarprefers not to use sophisticatealgorithms thare fficult to unrstan making the optimization approaless appropriate. No.PZ2023010903000028 (问答题)请问老师,这题没有强调要最小化tracking error。因为看题目中说fun模150 million,属于小规模投资者,从这个角度判断, stratifiesampling比full replication更合适。这个思路为什么不对?

2024-07-24 19:42 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2023010903000028 问题如下 Välimnext consirs the transition of the Funs portfolio holngs, whihave a totmarket value of EUR 150 million. She is constructing the portfolio using inviequities anconsirs the following metho: full replication, stratifiesampling, anoptimization. The benchmark for the portfolio is the FTSE Eurotop 100 Inx, whiis baseon market capitalization anconsists of 100 of the largest publicly traEuropecompanies. The investment committee prefers not to use sophisticatealgorithms thare fficult to unrstantermine, from the three metho thVälimis consiring, the most appropriate methofor constructing the equity portfolio. Justify your response. AnswerFull replication is suitable.The value of the Funs equity portfolio is EUR 150 million anis large enough to follow a full replication approaof the FTSE Eurotop 100 Inx. The constituents of this inx are the top 100 large capitalization Europeequities, whiare likely liquianavailable for trang. The full replication approarequires owning eaof the securities in the benchmark portfolio. Tracking error is likely to remain low sinthe number of constituents in this inx is not large.Stratifiesampling is less appropriate sinit es not trathe inx closely full replication, whiwoulresult in higher tracking error relative to full replication. The boarprefers not to use sophisticatealgorithms thare fficult to unrstan making the optimization approaless appropriate. the most appropriate methofor constructing the equity portfolio is full replication1.the funhave sufficient asset size of EUR 150 million to full replication.2.the full replication is appropriate with high liquity thconsists of inx is largest publicly tracompanies.3.easy to comprehenthmeet the committee's preference.

2024-07-22 23:43 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2023010903000028 问题如下 Välimnext consirs the transition of the Funs portfolio holngs, whihave a totmarket value of EUR 150 million. She is constructing the portfolio using inviequities anconsirs the following metho: full replication, stratifiesampling, anoptimization. The benchmark for the portfolio is the FTSE Eurotop 100 Inx, whiis baseon market capitalization anconsists of 100 of the largest publicly traEuropecompanies. The investment committee prefers not to use sophisticatealgorithms thare fficult to unrstantermine, from the three metho thVälimis consiring, the most appropriate methofor constructing the equity portfolio. Justify your response. AnswerFull replication is suitable.The value of the Funs equity portfolio is EUR 150 million anis large enough to follow a full replication approaof the FTSE Eurotop 100 Inx. The constituents of this inx are the top 100 large capitalization Europeequities, whiare likely liquianavailable for trang. The full replication approarequires owning eaof the securities in the benchmark portfolio. Tracking error is likely to remain low sinthe number of constituents in this inx is not large.Stratifiesampling is less appropriate sinit es not trathe inx closely full replication, whiwoulresult in higher tracking error relative to full replication. The boarprefers not to use sophisticatealgorithms thare fficult to unrstan making the optimization approaless appropriate. 这题到底怎么判断,老师能说下吗,我记得从以前哪里看过一个题,100只top的股票用低于500millionaum的规模是无法完全复制的,所以应该选择分层抽样的方式,怎么这里就说要完全复制了??那150million能买1000小盘股的inx吗?

2024-05-30 15:46 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2023010903000028 问题如下 Välimnext consirs the transition of the Funs portfolio holngs, whihave a totmarket value of EUR 150 million. She is constructing the portfolio using inviequities anconsirs the following metho: full replication, stratifiesampling, anoptimization. The benchmark for the portfolio is the FTSE Eurotop 100 Inx, whiis baseon market capitalization anconsists of 100 of the largest publicly traEuropecompanies. The investment committee prefers not to use sophisticatealgorithms thare fficult to unrstantermine, from the three metho thVälimis consiring, the most appropriate methofor constructing the equity portfolio. Justify your response. AnswerFull replication is suitable.The value of the Funs equity portfolio is EUR 150 million anis large enough to follow a full replication approaof the FTSE Eurotop 100 Inx. The constituents of this inx are the top 100 large capitalization Europeequities, whiare likely liquianavailable for trang. The full replication approarequires owning eaof the securities in the benchmark portfolio. Tracking error is likely to remain low sinthe number of constituents in this inx is not large.Stratifiesampling is less appropriate sinit es not trathe inx closely full replication, whiwoulresult in higher tracking error relative to full replication. The boarprefers not to use sophisticatealgorithms thare fficult to unrstan making the optimization approaless appropriate. The investment committee prefers not to use sophisticatealgorithms thare fficult to unrstan题干中没有提及对tracking error的偏好,也没有说在乎不在乎cost,但是解析里面是只是通过tracking error来排除stratifiesampling的。所以是代表inx里面,要优先选择tracking error小的吗?

2023-08-13 20:24 1 · 回答