开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

Bin · 2024年07月21日

这道题应该怎么改才能选B呢?

NO.PZ2023090506000008

问题如下:

An analyst is analyzing company XYZ and has gathered annual invested capital and ROIC for each of the three XYZ business segments.


Based on the information provided, XYZ’s management is most likely prone to which of the following biases?

选项:

A.

Inertia

B.

Sunk cost

C.

Pet project

解释:

A is correct. Inertia can be identified by examining the level of capital investment in total, by segment, or by business line, if disclosed, and comparing it to the prior year and the return on investment. If capital investment each year is static or rising despite falling returns on investment, the analyst should question the issuer’s justification for a capital investment and whether management should consider alternative uses. In the case of XYZ, we can observe that for segments A and B, ROIC is decreasing, but both segments are getting a higher capital allocation each year.

B is incorrect because sunk cost is related to the capital allocation process in determining a potential project’s profitability. Sunk costs, or those expenses that have already been incurred, should be ignored when evaluating potential projects.

C is incorrect because a detailed view of individual investment projects undertaken by XYZ’s management is not provided. Identifying pet projects from outside the firm is difficult, because financial statements are aggregated and such projects may not meet the threshold of materiality.

如题,老师我想问下这个表应该怎么改才能选B?C我理解是如果不给出额外条件只看表是得不出结论的,对吗?

1 个答案

王琛_品职助教 · 2024年07月22日

嗨,努力学习的PZer你好:


1)老师我想问下这个表应该怎么改才能选B?

1.1

站在出题人的角度,编这个表格,其实就是为了考查选项 A 的含义

如果要想改成选 B,那可能得重新编一个更符合沉没成本定义和特点的题干了

比如课后题第 1 题

具体分析,也请参考:https://class.pzacademy.com/qa/157794

2)C我理解是如果不给出额外条件只看表是得不出结论的,对吗?

是的

题干并没有提供具体的项目细节,或者是说这是管理层偏爱的项目,因此无法得出管理层存在 pet projects bias 的结论

----------------------------------------------
努力的时光都是限量版,加油!

  • 1

    回答
  • 0

    关注
  • 76

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2023090506000008 问题如下 analyst is analyzing company XYZ anhgathereannuinvestecapitanROIC for eaof the three XYZ business segments.Baseon the information provi XYZ’s management is most likely prone to whiof the following biases? A.Inerti B.Sunk cost C.Pet proje A is correct. Inertia cintifieexamining the level of capitinvestment in total, segment, or business line, if sclose ancomparing it to the prior yeanthe return on investment. If capitinvestment eayeis static or rising spite falling returns on investment, the analyst shoulquestion the issuer’s justification for a capitinvestment anwhether management shoulconsir alternative uses. In the case of XYZ, we cobserve thfor segments A anROIC is creasing, but both segments are getting a higher capitallocation eayear. B is incorrebecause sunk cost is relateto the capitallocation process in termining a potentiproject’s profitability. Sunk costs, or those expenses thhave alrea been incurre shoulignorewhen evaluating potentiprojects. C is incorrebecause a taileview of inviinvestment projects unrtaken XYZ’s management is not provi Intifying pet projects from outsi the firm is fficult, because financistatements are aggregateansuprojects mnot meet the thresholof materiality. 管理在继续对AB部门进行投资,即使其表现(通过ROIC表示)正在恶化。我觉得他们可能在试图通过额外的投资来“弥补”之前的资本支出,而不是根据当前的表现和未来的预期来做出决策所以我选择了沉没成本我看了一下惯性的,我不太理解“如果尽管投资回报在下降,但每年的资本投资保持不变或上升,分析师应该质疑发行人对资本投资的理由,以及管理层是否应该考虑其他用途。”

2024-02-01 17:02 1 · 回答