开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

wukefu · 2024年07月09日

taxable的客户不是应该避免更多的CGT吗

* 问题详情,请 查看题干

NO.PZ202209060200004306

问题如下:

Danny Moynahan, CFA, is a fixed-income portfolio manager at Reagan Investment Advisory (Reagan). His wife, Abigail Boyle, is a professor at a local university not far from their home. She is currently teaching an investments class. Over dinner one evening, she asks her husband if he will come and talk to her class about managing fixed-income portfolios. She believes it will be a useful experience for her students to hear from someone working in the investment industry. He agrees, and they plan for him to make his presentation the following week.

The next day at his office, with permission from his superior, Tom Gayle, Moynahan works on his presentation to the class. He plans to put together six pages for his discussion. He reviews the presentation materials he previously used at a conference to see if any of it would be useful. He decides page 1 should discuss the benefits of including fixed-income securities in a portfolio and highlights the following three points:

  • Point A: Adding fixed-income securities to a portfolio is an effective way of obtaining the benefits of diversification, especially because fixed-income correlations with other asset classes are low.

  • Point B: The regular nature of fixed-income cash flows enables investors to fund future obligations, unless there is a credit event.

  • Point C: Fixed-income securities can always provide a hedge for inflation, which results in superior risk-adjusted real portfolio returns.

On page 2, Moynahan decides to outline the three total return approaches he utilizes to manage Reagan’s fixed-income portfolios. He puts together the following exhibit:

Exhibit 1 Features of Total Return Portfolios

Moynahan titles page 3, “Liquidity in the Fixed-Income Market.” He wants to ensure that the class appreciates the differences in liquidity between fixed-income and equity securities. He stresses that liquidity across fixed-income securities varies greatly and that compared to equities, fixed-income markets are generally less liquid. Also, liquidity influences fixed-income pricing, but illiquidity enhances the portfolio’s yield to maturity. Lastly, dealers will narrow bid–ask spreads on thinly traded securities as a consequence of their illiquidity.

Tom Gayle, Moynahan’s superior, stops by Moynahan’s office. Moynahan shares his presentation with Gayle, who suggests that page 4 include a discussion about expected returns. They decide to outline an example of a recent bond trade where they bought a $100 par value bond at a premium. Moynahan presents a decomposition of the bond’s expected returns detailing various components and focuses on roll down return. He adds the following footnote: “The roll down return demonstrates how the price of a bond typically moves closer to par regardless of yield curve changes over the strategy horizon.”

Moynahan and Gayle continue their discussion about the presentation and debate several potential subjects to include on page 5. Gayle suggests assessing the use of leverage in the portfolios. They decide to present a scenario where the portfolio is fully invested, but given their outlook for a decline in interest rates, they want to increase the portfolio’s investment exposure. The portfolio and the benchmark both currently have the same duration.

On page 6, the final page of his presentation, Moynahan plans to discuss the tax implications of fixed-income investing. He wants the class to understand that the management of taxable portfolios is more complicated than that of tax-exempt portfolios. He outlines the following key considerations for managing taxable fixed-income portfolios:

  1. Minimize interest income relative to capital gains.

  2. Minimize capital gains relative to capital losses.

  3. Forego attractive trading opportunity because of tax implications.

Question


Which of the considerations outlined by Moynahan on page 6 of the presentation is least likely correct?

选项:

A.Consideration A B.Consideration B C.Consideration C

解释:

Solution

B is correct. When managing taxable fixed-income portfolios, Moynahan should not minimize capital gains relative to capital losses because capital losses are generally only used to offset capital gains.

A is incorrect. When managing taxable fixed-income portfolios, Moynahan would want to minimize interest income relative to capital gains because capital gains are typically taxed at a lower effective tax rate.

C is incorrect. When managing taxable fixed-income portfolios, Moynahan may want to dismiss attractive relative value trades due to tax implications.

老师上课说过,如果是taxable的客人,如果有两支股票,一个overvalue,一个undervalue,我们需要realise undervalue 的,这样就有一个地税的作用。


为什么题目中Minimize capital gains relative to capital losses. 对于 taxable的客户 是错的呢?


1 个答案
已采纳答案

pzqa31 · 2024年07月09日

嗨,从没放弃的小努力你好:


B这句话本身就不对,咱们仔细看看B这个选项,B的意思就是我就不喜欢capital gain,就得要capital loss。。。正常来讲,不管是出于什么考虑,做投资肯定不能尽量Minimize capital gain啊,虽然咱们讲过比如可以在年末确认capital loss来抵税,但这是有大前提的,并不是说为了避税就一直要让自己赔钱。

----------------------------------------------
虽然现在很辛苦,但努力过的感觉真的很好,加油!

  • 1

    回答
  • 0

    关注
  • 93

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ202209060200004306 问题如下 Whiof the consirations outlineMoynahon page 6 of the presentation is least likely correct? A.Consiration B.Consiration C.Consiration SolutionB is correct. When managing taxable fixeincome portfolios, Moynahshoulnot minimize capitgains relative to capitlosses because capitlosses are generally only useto offset capitgains.A is incorrect. When managing taxable fixeincome portfolios, Moynahwoulwant to minimize interest income relative to capitgains because capitgains are typically taxea lower effective trate.C is incorrect. When managing taxable fixeincome portfolios, Moynahmwant to smiss attractive relative value tras e to timplications. 老师好,针对这三个,我的理解是这样的Minimize interest income relative to capitgains.——我知道国债利息是免个人所得税的,其他利息应该有个人所得税?然后资本利得要交个人所得税?我不是很清楚这两个税税率哪个比较大。Minimize capitgains relative to capitlosses.——我觉得这个应该是对的吧?在有纳税义务的组合里面,capitloss可以抵税,因此相比于capitloss,最小化capitgain应该是对的?Forego attractive trang opportunity because of timplications.——因为税收问题放弃一些有吸引力的交易,这个我读起来应该是对的。所以我选了A,但是我也不确定利息收益和资本利得收益谁的税更高,麻烦老师一下谢谢。

2024-05-24 21:14 1 · 回答

NO.PZ202209060200004306 问题如下 Whiof the consirations outlineMoynahon page 6 of the presentation is least likely correct? A.Consiration B.Consiration C.Consiration SolutionB is correct. When managing taxable fixeincome portfolios, Moynahshoulnot minimize capitgains relative to capitlosses because capitlosses are generally only useto offset capitgains.A is incorrect. When managing taxable fixeincome portfolios, Moynahwoulwant to minimize interest income relative to capitgains because capitgains are typically taxea lower effective trate.C is incorrect. When managing taxable fixeincome portfolios, Moynahmwant to smiss attractive relative value tras e to timplications. 看了前面的答复,说是应该选A,A是least likely correct,B和C是对的,但是中又提到了Capitgain tax低于income tax,这样A为什么错,麻烦老师重新一下这道题的AB

2024-01-26 16:35 1 · 回答

NO.PZ202209060200004306 问题如下 Whiof the consirations outlineMoynahon page 6 of the presentation is least likely correct? A.Consiration B.Consiration C.Consiration SolutionB is correct. When managing taxable fixeincome portfolios, Moynahshoulnot minimize capitgains relative to capitlosses because capitlosses are generally only useto offset capitgains.A is incorrect. When managing taxable fixeincome portfolios, Moynahwoulwant to minimize interest income relative to capitgains because capitgains are typically taxea lower effective trate.C is incorrect. When managing taxable fixeincome portfolios, Moynahmwant to smiss attractive relative value tras e to timplications. PWM讲义里写capitgains are taxelower rate,上课也提到int income是不劳而获所以税率会更高一点,这和老师的回答说法不一样。。

2024-01-24 23:25 1 · 回答

NO.PZ202209060200004306问题如下Whiof the consirations outlineMoynahon page 6 of the presentation is least likely correct?A.Consiration AB.Consiration BC.Consiration CSolutionB is correct. When managing taxable fixeincome portfolios, Moynahshoulnot minimize capitgains relative to capitlosses because capitlosses are generally only useto offset capitgains.A is incorrect. When managing taxable fixeincome portfolios, Moynahwoulwant to minimize interest income relative to capitgains because capitgains are typically taxea lower effective trate.C is incorrect. When managing taxable fixeincome portfolios, Moynahmwant to smiss attractive relative value tras e to timplications.为什么助教说是A啊。请一下各

2023-07-23 14:34 2 · 回答