开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

wukefu · 2024年06月11日

蒙特卡洛模拟的作用是得到一个分布。而题目希望的是知道客户将来还需要多少钱来实现目标。所有不能选蒙特卡洛模拟。 这么理解对吗?

NO.PZ2021090805000018

问题如下:

Tom and his wife discussed retirement income goals and amounts with their investment advisor Johnson. They hope to maintain their current living standards after retirement and emphasize the importance of having confidence in achieving income goals for the rest of their lives.

According to Tom Tong's description of his retirement income goal, which of the following is the best method to analyze this goal?

选项:

A.

Annuity pricing

B.

Mortality tables

C.

Monte Carlo simulation

解释:

A is correct. Tom emphasized the importance of achieving the lifetime income goal of maintaining an inflation-adjusted current standard of living throughout retirement. Analyzing the pricing of joint lifetime annuity to ensure this goal is the best way to achieve it. A joint life annuity provide a series of guaranteed fixed payments, which can be exchanged for a one-time payment as long as any of them are still alive.

B is not correct. The mortality table shows a person's life expectancy at any specific age. One potential issue with using mortality tables as the only method to analyze Benetton's retirement goals is the probability that one or both of them will exceed the life expectancy of the general population. Therefore, they run the risk of outliving their assets and may need to reduce their annual income (spending) goal at some point.

C is incorrect. Monte Carlo simulation analyzed the likelihood of a client's actual investment portfolio meeting their anticipated retirement needs. Although Monte Carlo's output will include the probability of achieving Tom's goals, it cannot guarantee that their goals will be achieved, nor would it necessarily measure the “shortfall magnitude” to achieving their goal. Therefore, they run the risk of outliving their assets and may need to reduce their annual income (spending) goal at some point.

A是正确的。Tom强调了实现终身收入目标的重要性,即在整个退休期间保持经通胀调整的当前生活水平。通过对联合终身年金进行定价来分析这一目标是确保实现这一目标的最佳方法。联合终身年金提供了一系列有保证的固定支付,只要他们中的任何一个还活着,就可以换取一次性付款。

B不正确。死亡率表显示了一个人在任何特定年龄的预期寿命。将使用死亡率表作为分析贝纳通退休目标的唯一方法会有一个潜在问题,他们中的一个或两个的年龄超过普通人群预期寿命的概率。因此,他们面临着超过资产寿命的风险,可能需要在某个时候降低年收入(支出)目标。

C不正确。蒙特卡洛模拟分析了客户实际投资组合满足预期退休需求的可能性。尽管蒙特卡洛的产出将包括实现Tom目标的概率,但它不能保证他们的目标得到实现,也不一定能衡量实现目标的“缺口大小”。因此,他们面临着超过资产寿命的风险,可能需要在某个时候降低年收入(支出)目标。

蒙特卡洛模拟的作用是得到一个分布。而题目希望的是知道客户将来还需要多少钱来实现目标。所有不能选蒙特卡洛模拟。

这么理解对吗?

1 个答案
已采纳答案

王暄_品职助教 · 2024年06月11日

您的理解是正确的。蒙特卡洛模拟通常用于评估投资组合在不同市场环境下的可能表现,并提供达到某个财务目标的概率。然而,蒙特卡洛模拟的结果是一个概率分布,它展示了在不同情境下可能达成的投资结果,而不是一个确定性的结论。


在Tom和他妻子的案例中,他们强调了对实现终身收入目标的信心的重要性,这意味着他们想要一个更确定性的分析方法来评估他们的退休收入目标。因此,虽然蒙特卡洛模拟可以提供有关达到目标可能性的有用信息,但它并不能保证目标的实现,也无法准确衡量与目标之间的差距。

相比之下,年金定价(Annuity pricing)提供了一种保证终身收入的解决方案。通过购买一份联合终身年金,Tom和他的妻子可以确保在整个退休期间都能获得稳定的、经过通胀调整的收入,这更符合他们对于实现退休收入目标的期望。

所以,选择年金定价作为分析方法是正确的,因为它直接关联到他们想要达到的终身收入目标,并提供了确定性的保障。而蒙特卡洛模拟虽然有其用途,但在这个特定场景下,它并不是最佳的分析工具。

  • 1

    回答
  • 0

    关注
  • 143

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2021090805000018问题如下 Tom anhis wife scusseretirement income goals anamounts with their investment aisor Johnson. They hope to maintain their current living stanr after retirement anemphasize the importanof having confinin achieving income goals for the rest of their lives.Accorng to Tom Tong's scription of his retirement income goal, whiof the following is the best methoto analyze this goal? A.Annuity pricingB.Mortality tablesC.Monte Carlo simulation A is correct. Tom emphasizethe importanof achieving the lifetime income goof maintaining inflation-austecurrent stanrof living throughout retirement. Analyzing the pricing of joint lifetime annuity to ensure this gois the best wto achieve it. A joint life annuity provi a series of guaranteefixepayments, whicexchangefor a one-time payment long any of them are still alive.B is not correct. The mortality table shows a person's life expectanany specific age. One potentiissue with using mortality tables the only methoto analyze Benetton's retirement goals is the probability thone or both of them will exceethe life expectanof the generpopulation. Therefore, they run the risk of outliving their assets anmneeto retheir annuincome (spenng) gosome point.C is incorrect. Monte Carlo simulation analyzethe likelihooof a client's actuinvestment portfolio meeting their anticipateretirement nee. Although Monte Carlo's output will inclu the probability of achieving Tom's goals, it cannot guarantee ththeir goals will achieve nor woulit necessarily measure the “shortfall magnitu” to achieving their goal. Therefore, they run the risk of outliving their assets anmneeto retheir annuincome (spenng) gosome point.A是正确的。Tom强调了实现终身收入目标的重要性,即在整个退休期间保持经通胀调整的当前生活水平。通过对联合终身年金进行定价来分析这一目标是确保实现这一目标的最佳方法。联合终身年金提供了一系列有保证的固定支付,只要他们中的任何一个还活着,就可以换取一次性付款。B不正确。死亡率表显示了一个人在任何特定年龄的预期寿命。将使用死亡率表作为分析贝纳通退休目标的唯一方法会有一个潜在问题,他们中的一个或两个的年龄超过普通人群预期寿命的概率。因此,他们面临着超过资产寿命的风险,可能需要在某个时候降低年收入(支出)目标。C不正确。蒙特卡洛模拟分析了客户实际投资组合满足预期退休需求的可能性。尽管蒙特卡洛的产出将包括实现Tom目标的概率,但它不能保证他们的目标得到实现,也不一定能衡量实现目标的“缺口大小”。因此,他们面临着超过资产寿命的风险,可能需要在某个时候降低年收入(支出)目标。 这是我的推理 - Mortality table: when the client is worrieabout not ing unexpectey.Annuity: when the client wants to make sure a gois met.monte Carlo: when the client wants to know the situation unr fferent situations sutpolichange or suen inheritan

2024-06-18 23:50 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2021090805000018 问题如下 Tom anhis wife scusseretirement income goals anamounts with their investment aisor Johnson. They hope to maintain their current living stanr after retirement anemphasize the importanof having confinin achieving income goals for the rest of their lives.Accorng to Tom Tong's scription of his retirement income goal, whiof the following is the best methoto analyze this goal? A.Annuity pricing B.Mortality tables C.Monte Carlo simulation A is correct. Tom emphasizethe importanof achieving the lifetime income goof maintaining inflation-austecurrent stanrof living throughout retirement. Analyzing the pricing of joint lifetime annuity to ensure this gois the best wto achieve it. A joint life annuity provi a series of guaranteefixepayments, whicexchangefor a one-time payment long any of them are still alive.B is not correct. The mortality table shows a person's life expectanany specific age. One potentiissue with using mortality tables the only methoto analyze Benetton's retirement goals is the probability thone or both of them will exceethe life expectanof the generpopulation. Therefore, they run the risk of outliving their assets anmneeto retheir annuincome (spenng) gosome point.C is incorrect. Monte Carlo simulation analyzethe likelihooof a client's actuinvestment portfolio meeting their anticipateretirement nee. Although Monte Carlo's output will inclu the probability of achieving Tom's goals, it cannot guarantee ththeir goals will achieve nor woulit necessarily measure the “shortfall magnitu” to achieving their goal. Therefore, they run the risk of outliving their assets anmneeto retheir annuincome (spenng) gosome point.A是正确的。Tom强调了实现终身收入目标的重要性,即在整个退休期间保持经通胀调整的当前生活水平。通过对联合终身年金进行定价来分析这一目标是确保实现这一目标的最佳方法。联合终身年金提供了一系列有保证的固定支付,只要他们中的任何一个还活着,就可以换取一次性付款。B不正确。死亡率表显示了一个人在任何特定年龄的预期寿命。将使用死亡率表作为分析贝纳通退休目标的唯一方法会有一个潜在问题,他们中的一个或两个的年龄超过普通人群预期寿命的概率。因此,他们面临着超过资产寿命的风险,可能需要在某个时候降低年收入(支出)目标。C不正确。蒙特卡洛模拟分析了客户实际投资组合满足预期退休需求的可能性。尽管蒙特卡洛的产出将包括实现Tom目标的概率,但它不能保证他们的目标得到实现,也不一定能衡量实现目标的“缺口大小”。因此,他们面临着超过资产寿命的风险,可能需要在某个时候降低年收入(支出)目标。 如题

2024-04-06 15:45 1 · 回答