开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

大兵张嘎 · 2024年02月06日

这个答案逻辑上不通,成本不能反映价格有多种原因,和负的外部性没有直接逻辑关系呀?

NO.PZ2022120703000004

问题如下:

Negative externalities:

选项:

A.result from internalization of costs.

B.result in private costs that are higher than societal costs.

C.result in societal costs that are not reflected in the prices of goods.

解释:

C is correct because "the term externalities refers to situations where the production or consumption of goods and services creates costs or benefits to others that are not reflected in the prices charged for them...when externalities are negative, private costs are lower than societal costs...leading to 'market failures'...internalisation refers to all measures (public or private) to ensure that externalities become reflected in the prices of commercial goods and services."

A is incorrect because "...governments should tax polluters an amount equivalent to the cost of the harm incurred by others. Such a tax would yield the market outcome that would have prevailed with adequate internalisation of all costs by polluters. Internalisation refers to all measures (public or private) to ensure that externalities become reflected in the prices of commercial goods and services." Hence, internalization of costs would eliminate negative externalities.

B is incorrect because "when externalities are negative, private costs are lower than societal costs, resulting in market outcomes which may not be efficient or, in other words, leading to ‘market failures’."

逻辑好像有漏洞的,负外部性不是这么定义的吧?

1 个答案

净净_品职助教 · 2024年02月06日

嗨,爱思考的PZer你好:


习题解析:

负的外部性是指在生产或消费过程中产生的、未被市场价格反映的对第三方的负面影响。这意味着,当一个企业或个人在生产或消费某种产品时,他们可能会造成环境污染、公共健康问题等,这些影响并不会在产品的价格中得到体现,而是由社会整体来承担其成本。

选项C正确反映了负的外部性的本质:“导致社会成本未能通过商品价格反映出来”。这是因为,虽然生产或消费某个产品可能会带来额外的社会成本(例如,污染治理的费用、公共健康支出等),但这些成本并没有被包括在产品的销售价格中,导致产品的市场价格低于其真正的社会成本。


关于同学提到的逻辑问题,我来解释一下:

  • 成本未反映在价格中的多种原因:确实,成本可能因为多种原因未能反映在商品或服务的价格中。然而,在讨论负的外部性时,我们特别指的是那些由生产或消费活动直接引起的、但未在产品价格中体现的社会成本。这种情况下的“不反映”是指这些成本由非生产或消费该商品的人来承担,而不是由生产或消费者承担,这导致了市场失灵。这个解释并非哪个机构个体自己的解释,而是公认的一种定义。https://www.investopedia.com/terms/e/externality.asp
  • 为什么选项C是正确的:选项C正确地指出了负的外部性的一个关键特征——它们导致社会成本不通过商品或服务的价格来反映。这意味着,虽然生产和消费活动可能会给社会带来额外的成本,但这些成本并不体现在消费者支付的价格中。因此,市场机制无法有效分配资源,导致资源过度消耗或污染过度等市场失灵现象。


----------------------------------------------
就算太阳没有迎着我们而来,我们正在朝着它而去,加油!

  • 1

    回答
  • 1

    关注
  • 331

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2022120703000004问题如下Negative externalities:A.result from internalization of costs.B.result in private costs thare higher thsocietcosts.C.result in societcosts thare not reflectein the prices of goo. C is correct?because \"the term externalities refers to situations where the proction or consumption of goo anservices creates costs or benefits to others thare not reflectein the prices chargefor them...when externalities are negative, private costs are lower thsocietcosts...leang to 'market failures'...internalisation refers to all measures (public or private) to ensure thexternalities become reflectein the prices of commercigoo anservices.\" A is incorrebecause \"...governments shoultpolluters amount equivalent to the cost of the harm incurreothers. Sua twoulyielthe market outcome thwoulhave prevailewith aquate internalisation of all costs polluters. Internalisation refers to all measures (public or private) to ensure thexternalities become reflectein the prices of commercigoo anservices.\" Hence, internalization of costs wouleliminate negative externalities. B is incorrebecause \"when externalities are negative, private costs are lower thsocietcosts, resulting in market outcomes whimnot efficient or, in other wor, leang to ‘market failures’.\" negative externalities result from the costs not reflectein the price; alternatively, ththe costs not reflectein the prices result in the negative externalities. Is this correct?

2023-11-18 11:32 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2022120703000004 问题如下 Negative externalities: A.result from internalization of costs. B.result in private costs thare higher thsocietcosts. C.result in societcosts thare not reflectein the prices of goo. C is correct?because \"the term externalities refers to situations where the proction or consumption of goo anservices creates costs or benefits to others thare not reflectein the prices chargefor them...when externalities are negative, private costs are lower thsocietcosts...leang to 'market failures'...internalisation refers to all measures (public or private) to ensure thexternalities become reflectein the prices of commercigoo anservices.\" A is incorrebecause \"...governments shoultpolluters amount equivalent to the cost of the harm incurreothers. Sua twoulyielthe market outcome thwoulhave prevailewith aquate internalisation of all costs polluters. Internalisation refers to all measures (public or private) to ensure thexternalities become reflectein the prices of commercigoo anservices.\" Hence, internalization of costs wouleliminate negative externalities. B is incorrebecause \"when externalities are negative, private costs are lower thsocietcosts, resulting in market outcomes whimnot efficient or, in other wor, leang to ‘market failures’.\" Negative externalities:Aresult from internalization of costs.Bresult in private costs thare higher thsocietcosts.Cresult in societcosts thare not reflectein the prices of goo.

2023-05-22 17:43 1 · 回答