开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)｜3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

返回

139****6474 · 2023年12月24日

为什么不可以从现有的独立董事里选择信任董事长？

  1. ESG
  2. Governance factors

NO.PZ2022120702000018

问题如下：

CBT’s Annual General Meeting (AGM) is two months away. Patrick Weeze is a portfolio manager who owns a significant number of CBT shares in his portfolio. His fund is a concentrated portfolio with high idiosyncratic risk and, as a result, Patrick believes that a detailed analysis of the governance of each of his portfolio holdings is paramount to its long-term performance. He reviews the relevant documentation regarding CBT’s AGM and notes the following:

− CBT currently has 10 individuals sitting on its board, 3 of whom are independent. The Chairman is the former CEO who stepped down last year.

Patrick believes that the Chair cannot be considered as an independent member of the board. He schedules an engagement meeting with the Chair to discuss the matter.

What could be the most favourable outcome from a governance perspective?

选项：

A.The Chair steps down and the CEO assumes the chairmanship, and one of the independent directors becomes the lead independent director. B.The Chair steps down and remains on the board, and one of the existing independent directors is elected Chair. C.An additional independent director is added to the board to increase the level of independence. D.The Chair steps down from the Chair role, and a newly elected independent director is appointed Chair.

解释：

CBT目前有10位董事，其中3位是独立董事。董事会主席是去年离职的前任首席执行官。Patrick认为，主席不能被视为董事会的独立成员。他安排与主席开会讨论此事。从治理的角度来看，最有利的结果就是D选项，董事会主席辞去其职务，新选出的独立董事被任命为董事长，保证董事会主席的独立性。

为什么不可以从现有的独立董事里选择信任董事长？

添加评论
2 个答案

净净_品职助教 · 2023年12月25日

嗨，从没放弃的小努力你好：


董事会中独立董事的数量或比例要求因国家和地区的法律、规章以及公司所在的股票交易所的规则而异。不过，一般有一些普遍的准则和最佳实践（以下部分与考试无关，可做拓展学习，知识点还是以讲义和课程内容为准）：

  1. 美国：在美国，纳斯达克和纽约证券交易所要求上市公司的董事会必须至少有一半的独立董事。对于某些委员会，如审计、薪酬和提名委员会，几乎必须完全由独立董事组成。
  2. 欧洲：欧洲的规定各有不同。例如，在英国，上市公司治理的金融报告委员会（FRC）的《英国公司治理准则》建议至少一半（不包括董事长）的董事应该是独立非执行董事。
  3. 亚洲：亚洲各国的规定也不尽相同。例如，香港的上市规则要求董事会至少有三名独立非执行董事，占董事总数的不少于三分之一。
  4. 独立执行董事与独立非执行董事：一般而言，独立执行董事较少见，因为执行董事通常涉及公司的日常管理，而独立性可能难以保证。独立非执行董事则更加常见，他们不参与公司的日常管理，更能保持独立性，提供监督和建议。

----------------------------------------------
加油吧，让我们一起遇见更好的自己！

净净_品职助教 · 2023年12月24日

嗨，爱思考的PZer你好：


同学应该是对B选项有疑问，选现有的独立董事当出席并没有什么问题，但并不一定是最优解。

B选项主席卸任，但仍留在董事会，现有的一名独立董事当选为主席。

D选项主席辞去主席职务，新选举的独立董事被任命为主席。

区别在于B的主席仍然在董事会里，董事会结构仍然只有3位独立董事。D选项主席走了，换了个独立董事，现在董事会里有4个独立董事了，独立性提高

----------------------------------------------
努力的时光都是限量版，加油！

139****6474 · 2023年12月25日

请问董事会针对独立和非独立董事的席位有个数量级的规定和建议吗？

  • 2

    回答

  • 1

    关注

  • 237

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2022120702000018 问题如下 CBT’s AnnuGenerMeeting (AGM) is two months away. PatriWeeze is a portfolio manager who owns a significant number of Cshares in his portfolio. His funis a concentrateportfolio with high iosyncratic risk an a result, Patribelieves tha taileanalysis of the governanof eaof his portfolio holngs is paramount to its long-term performance. He reviews the relevant cumentation regarng CBT’s AGM annotes the following: − Ccurrently h10 invials sitting on its boar 3 of whom are inpennt. The Chairmis the former CEO who steppewn last year.Patribelieves ththe Chair cannot consireinpennt member of the boar He scheles engagement meeting with the Chair to scuss the matter. Whcoulthe most favourable outcome from a governanperspective? A.The Chair steps wn anthe CEO assumes the chairmanship, anone of the inpennt rectors becomes the leinpennt rector. B.The Chair steps wn anremains on the boar anone of the existing inpennt rectors is electeChair. C.aitioninpennt rector is aeto the boarto increase the level of inpennce. The Chair steps wn from the Chair role, ana newly electeinpennt rector is appointeChair. CBT目前有10位董事，其中3位是独立董事。董事会主席是去年离职的前任首席执行官。Patrick认为，主席不能被视为董事会的独立成员。他安排与主席开会讨论此事。从治理的角度来看，最有利的结果就是董事会主席辞去其职务，新选出的独立董事被任命为董事长，保证董事会主席的独立性。 B为什么不对

2024-06-22 20:39 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2022120702000018 问题如下 CBT’s AnnuGenerMeeting (AGM) is two months away. PatriWeeze is a portfolio manager who owns a significant number of Cshares in his portfolio. His funis a concentrateportfolio with high iosyncratic risk an a result, Patribelieves tha taileanalysis of the governanof eaof his portfolio holngs is paramount to its long-term performance. He reviews the relevant cumentation regarng CBT’s AGM annotes the following: − Ccurrently h10 invials sitting on its boar 3 of whom are inpennt. The Chairmis the former CEO who steppewn last year.Patribelieves ththe Chair cannot consireinpennt member of the boar He scheles engagement meeting with the Chair to scuss the matter. Whcoulthe most favourable outcome from a governanperspective? A.The Chair steps wn anthe CEO assumes the chairmanship, anone of the inpennt rectors becomes the leinpennt rector. B.The Chair steps wn anremains on the boar anone of the existing inpennt rectors is electeChair. C.aitioninpennt rector is aeto the boarto increase the level of inpennce. The Chair steps wn from the Chair role, ana newly electeinpennt rector is appointeChair. CBT目前有10位董事，其中3位是独立董事。董事会主席是去年离职的前任首席执行官。Patrick认为，主席不能被视为董事会的独立成员。他安排与主席开会讨论此事。从治理的角度来看，最有利的结果就是董事会主席辞去其职务，新选出的独立董事被任命为董事长，保证董事会主席的独立性。 C 多一个独立董事人数了啊，而且一般公司怎么会由一个独立董事来当董事人，独立董事都是外部人，董事长这种核心掌权人，啥时候轮到外人了。

2024-06-10 09:42 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2022120702000018 问题如下 CBT’s AnnuGenerMeeting (AGM) is two months away. PatriWeeze is a portfolio manager who owns a significant number of Cshares in his portfolio. His funis a concentrateportfolio with high iosyncratic risk an a result, Patribelieves tha taileanalysis of the governanof eaof his portfolio holngs is paramount to its long-term performance. He reviews the relevant cumentation regarng CBT’s AGM annotes the following: − Ccurrently h10 invials sitting on its boar 3 of whom are inpennt. The Chairmis the former CEO who steppewn last year.Patribelieves ththe Chair cannot consireinpennt member of the boar He scheles engagement meeting with the Chair to scuss the matter. Whcoulthe most favourable outcome from a governanperspective? A.The Chair steps wn anthe CEO assumes the chairmanship, anone of the inpennt rectors becomes the leinpennt rector. B.The Chair steps wn anremains on the boar anone of the existing inpennt rectors is electeChair. C.aitioninpennt rector is aeto the boarto increase the level of inpennce. The Chair steps wn from the Chair role, ana newly electeinpennt rector is appointeChair. CBT目前有10位董事，其中3位是独立董事。董事会主席是去年离职的前任首席执行官。Patrick认为，主席不能被视为董事会的独立成员。他安排与主席开会讨论此事。从治理的角度来看，最有利的结果就是董事会主席辞去其职务，新选出的独立董事被任命为董事长，保证董事会主席的独立性。 加一个独立董事没问题，但上哪找一个新人直接当chairman，不是直接从10个人里选一个更合适吗。没有人会给这种建议吧，感觉比较无理要求

2024-05-28 18:07 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2022120702000018问题如下 CBT’s AnnuGenerMeeting (AGM) is two months away. PatriWeeze is a portfolio manager who owns a significant number of Cshares in his portfolio. His funis a concentrateportfolio with high iosyncratic risk an a result, Patribelieves tha taileanalysis of the governanof eaof his portfolio holngs is paramount to its long-term performance. He reviews the relevant cumentation regarng CBT’s AGM annotes the following: − Ccurrently h10 invials sitting on its boar 3 of whom are inpennt. The Chairmis the former CEO who steppewn last year.Patribelieves ththe Chair cannot consireinpennt member of the boar He scheles engagement meeting with the Chair to scuss the matter. Whcoulthe most favourable outcome from a governanperspective? A.The Chair steps wn anthe CEO assumes the chairmanship, anone of the inpennt rectors becomes the leinpennt rector.B.The Chair steps wn anremains on the boar anone of the existing inpennt rectors is electeChair.C.aitioninpennt rector is aeto the boarto increase the level of inpennce.The Chair steps wn from the Chair role, ana newly electeinpennt rector is appointeChair.CBT目前有10位董事，其中3位是独立董事。董事会主席是去年离职的前任首席执行官。Patrick认为，主席不能被视为董事会的独立成员。他安排与主席开会讨论此事。从治理的角度来看，最有利的结果就是董事会主席辞去其职务，新选出的独立董事被任命为董事长，保证董事会主席的独立性。一下题目和 谢谢老师

2024-05-06 21:03 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2022120702000018 问题如下 CBT’s AnnuGenerMeeting (AGM) is two months away. PatriWeeze is a portfolio manager who owns a significant number of Cshares in his portfolio. His funis a concentrateportfolio with high iosyncratic risk an a result, Patribelieves tha taileanalysis of the governanof eaof his portfolio holngs is paramount to its long-term performance. He reviews the relevant cumentation regarng CBT’s AGM annotes the following: − Ccurrently h10 invials sitting on its boar 3 of whom are inpennt. The Chairmis the former CEO who steppewn last year.Patribelieves ththe Chair cannot consireinpennt member of the boar He scheles engagement meeting with the Chair to scuss the matter. Whcoulthe most favourable outcome from a governanperspective? A.The Chair steps wn anthe CEO assumes the chairmanship, anone of the inpennt rectors becomes the leinpennt rector. B.The Chair steps wn anremains on the boar anone of the existing inpennt rectors is electeChair. C.aitioninpennt rector is aeto the boarto increase the level of inpennce. The Chair steps wn from the Chair role, ana newly electeinpennt rector is appointeChair. CBT目前有10位董事，其中3位是独立董事。董事会主席是去年离职的前任首席执行官。Patrick认为，主席不能被视为董事会的独立成员。他安排与主席开会讨论此事。从治理的角度来看，最有利的结果就是董事会主席辞去其职务，新选出的独立董事被任命为董事长，保证董事会主席的独立性。 为什么我觉得答案B和的是一个意思，答案B说chair下来但继续留在董事会，选一个已有的独立董事为新的chair。答案不过是说下来，新选的独立董事为Chair。感觉意思区别不大

2024-04-21 20:51 1 · 回答