开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

RyanR · 2023年10月26日

什么叫risk a Type I error?

NO.PZ2018122701000033

问题如下:

Basel II requires a backtest of a bank’s internal value at risk (VaR) model (IMA). Assume the bank’s ten-day 99% VaR is $1 million (minimum of 99% is hard-wired per Basel). The null hypothesis is: the VaR model is accurate. Out of 1,000 observations, 25 exceptions are observed (we saw the actual loss exceed the VaR 25 out of 1000 observations).  (Binomial CDF)

选项:

A.

We will probably call the VaR model good (accurate) but we risk a Type I error.

B.

We will probably call the VaR model good (accurate) but we risk a Type II error.

C.

We will probably call the model bad (inaccurate) but we risk a Type I error.

D.

We will probably call the model bad (inaccurate) but we risk a Type II error.

解释:

C is correct.

考点 : Backtesting VaR

解析 :H0 : the VaR model is accurate. Hα: the VaR model is inaccurate.

Z=xpTp(1p)T=251%×10001%×(11%)×1000=4.77Z=\frac{x-pT}{\sqrt{p(1-p)T}}=\frac{25-1\%\times1000}{\sqrt{1\%\times(1-1\%)\times1000}}=4.77

As 4.77 is larger than 2.58, we reject the null hypothesis. Therefore, the model is bad model, and this implies a risk of type I error.

大概能懂题意,我们对银行的一个模型进行backtesing, 然后银行的模型给的VaR是99%,而我们实际测出来的是1000次25个exception。所以我们的结论是这个模型不准,但是因为原假设H0是模型是准确的,而我们的结果拒绝了原假设,所以我们犯了一类错误?


有点懵了,那我们既然犯错误了,那对于这个model不准确的结论成立吗?或者说这个犯一类错误的意义是啥,有点没懂。不知道表达清楚没有。

2 个答案

pzqa27 · 2023年11月08日

嗨,爱思考的PZer你好:


这个题的意思很简单,本来银行搞了一个VaR模型,本来根据银行的模型,只能有10天击穿VaR,现在有25天击穿了VaR,那么我们要看一下,这25天跟10天比是否是显著的,也就是说,本来应该有10天击穿VaR,假如说真实的击穿天数是11天,我们还可能认为多出的一天属于合理的误差范围内,现在有25天击穿了,多出了15天,根据假设检验,25天显然是无法近似于10天的,因此我们判断这个模型不算个好模型,相当于我们拒绝了这个模型,因此我们拒真的可能性,就是说这个模型可能是好的,但是我们判断错了。

----------------------------------------------
就算太阳没有迎着我们而来,我们正在朝着它而去,加油!

pzqa27 · 2023年10月26日

嗨,努力学习的PZer你好:


这里是在做假设检验,相当于断案,一类错误就是说,这个原假设本来是个好人,我们断案断错了,把好人给杀了。

1类错误的概率就是我们错杀好人的概率。

----------------------------------------------
就算太阳没有迎着我们而来,我们正在朝着它而去,加油!

RyanR · 2023年11月08日

您举的例子我能理解。但是现在这个模型只是假设是准确的,事实上并不一定就是正确的啊。如果这个模型是准确的,而我们拒绝了,那我可以理解是犯了一类错误。 但现在只是判断这个假设对不对而已,那我只要结论和假设不一样,就算犯一类错误了?

  • 2

    回答
  • 0

    关注
  • 244

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2018122701000033 问题如下 Basel II requires a backtest of a bank’s internal value risk (VaR) mol (IMA). Assume the bank’s ten-y 99% Vis $1 million (minimum of 99% is harwireper Basel). The null hypothesis is: the Vmol is accurate. Out of 1,000 observations, 25 exceptions are observed (we sthe actuloss exceethe V25 out of 1000 observations).  (BinomiC) We will probably call the Vmol good (accurate) but we risk a Type I error. We will probably call the Vmol good (accurate) but we risk a Type II error. We will probably call the mol bad (inaccurate) but we risk a Type I error. We will probably call the mol bad (inaccurate) but we risk a Type II error. C is correct. 考点 Backtesting V解析 H0 : the Vmol is accurate. Hα: the Vmol is inaccurate.Z=x−pTp(1−p)T=25−1%×10001%×(1−1%)×1000=4.77Z=\frac{x-pT}{\sqrt{p(1-p)T}}=\frac{25-1\%\times1000}{\sqrt{1\%\times(1-1\%)\times1000}}=4.77Z=p(1−p)T​x−pT​=1%×(1−1%)×1000​25−1%×1000​=4.774.77 is larger th2.58, we rejethe null hypothesis. Therefore, the mol is bmol, anthis implies a risk of type I error. 我可以计算出Z= (x-pxT)/sqt[px(1-p)xT] = (25-1%x1000)/sqt[1x(1-1%)x1000] = 4.77 大于2.58,所以拒绝原假设,因此这是一个bmol。但是从哪判断这是Type I 还是type II risk? 看了之前的,还是不知道什么意思。

2024-10-05 14:14 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2018122701000033问题如下 Basel II requires a backtest of a bank’s internal value risk (VaR) mol (IMA). Assume the bank’s ten-y 99% Vis $1 million (minimum of 99% is harwireper Basel). The null hypothesis is: the Vmol is accurate. Out of 1,000 observations, 25 exceptions are observed (we sthe actuloss exceethe V25 out of 1000 observations).  (BinomiC) We will probably call the Vmol good (accurate) but we risk a Type I error. We will probably call the Vmol good (accurate) but we risk a Type II error. We will probably call the mol bad (inaccurate) but we risk a Type I error. We will probably call the mol bad (inaccurate) but we risk a Type II error. C is correct. 考点 Backtesting V解析 H0 : the Vmol is accurate. Hα: the Vmol is inaccurate.Z=x−pTp(1−p)T=25−1%×10001%×(1−1%)×1000=4.77Z=\frac{x-pT}{\sqrt{p(1-p)T}}=\frac{25-1\%\times1000}{\sqrt{1\%\times(1-1\%)\times1000}}=4.77Z=p(1−p)T​x−pT​=1%×(1−1%)×1000​25−1%×1000​=4.774.77 is larger th2.58, we rejethe null hypothesis. Therefore, the mol is bmol, anthis implies a risk of type I error. 如果是bmol就存在 type I error,goomol就存在type II error是这样吗?

2024-08-06 15:00 2 · 回答

NO.PZ2018122701000033问题如下 Basel II requires a backtest of a bank’s internal value risk (VaR) mol (IMA). Assume the bank’s ten-y 99% Vis $1 million (minimum of 99% is harwireper Basel). The null hypothesis is: the Vmol is accurate. Out of 1,000 observations, 25 exceptions are observed (we sthe actuloss exceethe V25 out of 1000 observations).  (BinomiC) We will probably call the Vmol good (accurate) but we risk a Type I error. We will probably call the Vmol good (accurate) but we risk a Type II error. We will probably call the mol bad (inaccurate) but we risk a Type I error. We will probably call the mol bad (inaccurate) but we risk a Type II error. C is correct. 考点 Backtesting V解析 H0 : the Vmol is accurate. Hα: the Vmol is inaccurate.Z=x−pTp(1−p)T=25−1%×10001%×(1−1%)×1000=4.77Z=\frac{x-pT}{\sqrt{p(1-p)T}}=\frac{25-1\%\times1000}{\sqrt{1\%\times(1-1\%)\times1000}}=4.77Z=p(1−p)T​x−pT​=1%×(1−1%)×1000​25−1%×1000​=4.774.77 is larger th2.58, we rejethe null hypothesis. Therefore, the mol is bmol, anthis implies a risk of type I error. 这个题可不可以另一种解法,回测的标准是99%,所以p=0.01,代入T=1000,和z=2.58,反求x,算出x=18+。而题目说exceptions是25,则说明这个模型做的不好,25在拒绝域,易犯第一类错误,这样也能得出正确答案

2023-07-21 23:37 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2018122701000033 问题如下 Basel II requires a backtest of a bank’s internal value risk (VaR) mol (IMA). Assume the bank’s ten-y 99% Vis $1 million (minimum of 99% is harwireper Basel). The null hypothesis is: the Vmol is accurate. Out of 1,000 observations, 25 exceptions are observed (we sthe actuloss exceethe V25 out of 1000 observations).  (BinomiC) We will probably call the Vmol good (accurate) but we risk a Type I error. We will probably call the Vmol good (accurate) but we risk a Type II error. We will probably call the mol bad (inaccurate) but we risk a Type I error. We will probably call the mol bad (inaccurate) but we risk a Type II error. C is correct. 考点 Backtesting V解析 H0 : the Vmol is accurate. Hα: the Vmol is inaccurate.Z=x−pTp(1−p)T=25−1%×10001%×(1−1%)×1000=4.77Z=\frac{x-pT}{\sqrt{p(1-p)T}}=\frac{25-1\%\times1000}{\sqrt{1\%\times(1-1\%)\times1000}}=4.77Z=p(1−p)T​x−pT​=1%×(1−1%)×1000​25−1%×1000​=4.774.77 is larger th2.58, we rejethe null hypothesis. Therefore, the mol is bmol, anthis implies a risk of type I error. 如题

2023-01-13 00:46 1 · 回答