开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

大瓶子 · 2023年08月19日

一般从哪些指标来看,报表有更高的盈利能力?

NO.PZ2023020602000214

问题如下:

An analyst is analyzing two companies in the same industry and believes that they have similar strategies regarding the use of property, plant, and equipment (PP&E). He also thinks that the PP&E assets of the two companies are roughly of the same age and have the same expected useful lives remaining. Company A uses the LIFO method of inventory valuation, and Company B uses the FIFO method. The following additional information is available from the companies’ financial statements ($ millions):


In the analyst’s opinion, which of the following conclusions is most appropriate? Compared with Company A, Company B:

选项:

A.is more liquid. B.has a higher quality of earnings. C.uses more aggressive accounting estimates related to PP&E.

解释:

The analyst believes the two companies’ PP&E are of the same age; however, the useful life remaining for Company B’s assets is 15 years compared with 10 for Company A, implying B is using a longer useful life or more aggressive accounting policies.

The more aggressive PP&E estimates combined with the use of FIFO indicate that Company B has a lower quality of earnings, not higher. The adjusted current ratio for Company A (adjusted to include the LIFO reserve to convert the balance sheet to FIFO for comparison) is higher than the current ratio for B, indicating that A is more liquid.

1,盈利能力应该是可以量化对比的,采用LIFO就一定比FIFO有更高的盈利能力吗?本文没有强调存货价格是上升还是下降呀。

2,报表有更高的盈利能力,原版中一般从哪几个指标来看?

1 个答案

lynn_品职助教 · 2023年08月20日

嗨,爱思考的PZer你好:


1、这里不需要量化,不过同学考虑的是对的,题目没有特意讲的时候是有一个早买的存货价格低的假设,FIFO是first in first out,通常最早买入的价格可能相对偏低,说明CPGS成本低,所以收益就虚高了。


LIFO reserve是FIFO下的Inventory值 - LIFO下的Inventory值。 不是两者的COGS相减。


我们可以认为LIFO下的COGS = LIFO下库存的期初 + 新入库存的值 - LIFO下的器末库存值


我们可以认为FIFO下的COGS = FIFO下库存的期初 + 新入库存的值 - FIFO下的器末库存值


新买入的东西的成本肯定两种方法都是一样的。 所以


COGS(FIFO)- COGS (LIFO)


= FIFO下库存的期初 + 新入库存的值 - FIFO下的器末库存值 -(LIFO下库存的期初 + 新入库存的值 - LIFO下的器末库存值)


= (FIFO下库存的期初 - LIFO下库存的期初) - (FIFO下的器末库存值- LIFO下的器末库存值)


= LIFO reserve 期初 - LIFO reserve 期末 = - Increase of LIFO reserve


2、ROE、ROA、EV/EBITDA和市盈率等与收益有关的指标都是与盈利能力有关的,不过这道题其实是想考察报表的质量如何。

一般来说,低估了成本,所以收益就虚高了,表明B公司的收益质量较低。


----------------------------------------------
努力的时光都是限量版,加油!

  • 1

    回答
  • 0

    关注
  • 252

    浏览