开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

卢天悦 · 2023年08月05日

从turnover这里可以看出来什么吗?

NO.PZ2023012803000008

问题如下:

Richard Seal manages his own investment portfolio and meets with Michelle Beech, an investment advisor. Richard tells Beech that his equity portfolio has outperformed and he is certain it would continue to outperform under his management. However, demands on his time have increased and he now needs some assistance.

Beech calculates the performance of Richard’s self-managed equity portfolio and compares the results with the median active equity mutual fund and a passive equity index fund in Exhibit 1. Beech concludes that Richard has overconfidence bias.

Exhibit 1 Selected Portfolio Characteristics


Support Beech’s conclusion with two reasons.

选项:

解释:

Overconfidence bias occurs when people demonstrate unwarranted faith in their own abilities. Richard exhibits this in two ways:

Richard’s belief that his outperformance would continue despite not outperforming in the past indicates overconfidence. This is an example of overconfidence bias that occurs when the probabilities assigned to outcomes are too high because individuals are too certain of their judgments.

Richard maintains a poorly diversified portfolio, with 50% of total assets held in 5 companies, versus the more diversified mutual fund and index funds. When estimating the future value of a stock, investors with overconfidence bias will incorporate too little variation – using a narrower range of expected payoffs and a lower standard deviation of returns – than justified based on historical results and fundamental analysis. Such an investor may underestimate the risks, particularly downside risks, and consequently hold a poorly diversified portfolio.

可以说他的turnover比equity index的要高很多,但实际获得的收益是和equity index一样,所以他对于对市场情况、交易价格的把控过于自信吗

2 个答案
已采纳答案

王琛_品职助教 · 2023年08月07日

嗨,从没放弃的小努力你好:


0

我个人认为,从 turnover 这里,没法证明 Richard 有 overconfidence bias 哈

或者说,相比于 turnover,另外两个维度(net return 和 top 5 holdings)作为证据更有说服力

1

题目要我们提供两个 Richard 有 overconfidence bias 的证据

表格中提供了三个对比的维度:net return,top 5 holdings,turnover

每个维度又提供了两个可比项:股票基金的中位数、被动管理的股票指数基金

2

不论是 net return,还是 top 5 holdings

通过与股票基金的中位数、被动管理的股票指数基金对比,都能得到相同的结论,即 Richard 有 overconfidence bias

3

但是分析维度 turnover 时,结论并不统一

如果是和股票基金的中位数对比,其实 Richard 并没有过度交易,因为其 turnover (45%),低于股票基金的中位数(65%)

相当于和同行比,其实 Richard 并不严格属于过度交易,起码比同行的 turnover 要低

4

如果是和被动管理的股票指数基金对比,确实是过度交易。因为其 turnover (45%),高于被动管理的股票指数基金(18%)

相当于和另一种投资风格相比,属于过度交易

5

但是这两个对比的结果不统一

不像其他两个维度(net return 和 top 5 holdings)能得到相同的分析结论

所以我个人认为,这道题写另外两个维度,会更严谨更好

----------------------------------------------
就算太阳没有迎着我们而来,我们正在朝着它而去,加油!

卢天悦 · 2023年08月07日

明白,谢谢!

王琛_品职助教 · 2023年08月07日

嗨,从没放弃的小努力你好:


明白,谢谢! 

同学客气了

如果学习过程中遇到什么学术问题,都欢迎随时在有问必答提问哈,加油~ 

----------------------------------------------
就算太阳没有迎着我们而来,我们正在朝着它而去,加油!

  • 2

    回答
  • 0

    关注
  • 238

    浏览
相关问题