NO.PZ2022071403000013
问题如下:
Question Which of the following statements with respect to Giffen and Veblen goods is least accurate?
选项:
A.Giffen goods are “inferior,” whereas Veblen goods are “high-status” goods.
B.The highly negative income effect overpowers the substitution effect for both types of goods.
C.Both types of goods demonstrate the possibility of a positively sloping demand curve.
解释:
Solution
B is correct. The overwhelming nature of the highly negative income effect over the substitution effect is applicable to Giffen goods only. Veblen goods are highly valued, high-priced “status” goods; consumers may tend to buy more of a Veblen good if its price rises.
A is incorrect. It is true that Giffen goods are “inferior” whereas Veblen goods are “high-status” goods.
C is incorrect. It is true that both Giffen goods and Veblen goods demonstrate the possibility of a positively sloping demand curve.
中文解析:
B正确。高度负的收入效应压倒替代效应的压倒性性质只适用于吉芬商品。凡勃伦商品是价值很高、价格很高的“身份”商品;如果凡勃伦产品的价格上涨,消费者可能倾向于购买更多的产品。
A不正确。吉芬商品是“劣等”商品,而凡勃伦商品是“高级”商品,这是事实。
C是不正确的。的确,吉芬商品和凡勃伦商品都证明了需求曲线斜率为正的可能性。
(1)请问老师b的错误点是什么?
(2)韦伯仑商品无理论支撑 所以不可以用替代效应和收入效应分析,这样理解对吗?