开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)｜3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

返回

ivyyang · 2023年04月24日

分子为何不需要对cashflow进行权重调整？

  1. CFA III
  2. GIPS

NO.PZ2022010501000005

问题如下：

A European equity composite contains three portfolios whose cash flow weighting factors are as follows.


A Calculate the returns of Portfolio A, Portfolio B, and Portfolio C for the month of August using Modified Dietz formula.

B Calculate the August composite return by asset-weighting the individual portfolio returns using beginning-of- period values.

C Calculate the August composite return by asset- weighting the individual portfolio returns using a method that reflects both beginning-of-period values and external cash flows.

解释：

A Portfolio returns:

rA=85.3−74.9−7.574.9+（7.5×0.613）=2.979.5=0.0365=3.65%r_A=\frac{85.3-74.9-7.5}{74.9+（7.5\times0.613）}=\frac{2.9}{79.5}=0.0365=3.65\%

rB=109.8−127.6−(−15)−(−5)127.6+（−15×0.742）+(−5×0.387）=2.2114.535=0.0192=1.92%r_B=\frac{109.8-127.6-(-15)-(-5)}{127.6+（-15\times0.742）+(-5\times0.387）}=\frac{2.2}{114.535}=0.0192=1.92\%

rC=128.4−110.4−15110.4+（15×0.387）=3116.205=0.0258=2.58%r_C=\frac{128.4-110.4-15}{110.4+（15\times0.387）}=\frac3{116.205}=0.0258=2.58\%

B To calculate the composite return based on beginning assets, first determine the percentage of beginning composite assets represented by each portfolio; then determine the weighted-average return for the month:

Beginning composite assets = 74.9 + 127.6 + 110.4 = 312.9

Portfolio A = 74.9/312.9 = 0.239 = 23.9%

Portfolio B = 127.6/312.9 = 0.408 = 40.8%

Portfolio C = 110.4/312.9 = 0.353 = 35.3%

rComp=  (0.0365  ×  0.239)  +  (0.0192  ×  0.408)  +  (0.0258  ×  0.353)=  0.0257  =  2.57%r_{Comp}=\;(0.0365\;\times\;0.239)\;+\;(0.0192\;\times\;0.408)\;+\;(0.0258\;\times\;0.353)=\;0.0257\;=\;2.57\%


C To calculate the composite return based on beginning assets plus cash flows, first use the denominator of the Modified Dietz formula to determine the percentage of total beginning assets plus weighted cash flows represented by each portfolio, and then calculate the weighted-average return:

Beginning composite assets + Weighted cash flows = [74.9 + (7.5 × 0.613)] + [127.6 + (−15 × 0.742) + (−5 × 0.387)] + [110.4 + (15 × 0.387)] = 79.5 + 114.535 + 116.205 = 310.24

Portfolio A = 79.5/310.24 = 0.256 = 25.6%

Portfolio B = 114.535/310.24 = 0.369 = 36.9%

Portfolio C = 116.205/310.24 = 0.375 = 37.5%

rComp  =  (0.0365  ×  0.256)  +  (0.0192  ×  0.369)  +  (0.0258  ×  0.375)    =  0.0261  =  2.61%r_{Comp}\;=\;(0.0365\;\times\;0.256)\;+\;(0.0192\;\times\;0.369)\;+\;(0.0258\;\times\;0.375)\;\;=\;0.0261\;=\;2.61\%


The Aggregate Return method is calculated by summing beginning assets and intra- period external cash flows, treating the entire composite as though it were a single portfolio and then computing the return directly with the Modified Dietz formula.

rComp  =  323.5−312.9−(−15+7.5+10)312.9+[(−15)×0.742+7.5×0.613+10×0.387]=  0.0261  =  2.61%r_{Comp}\;=\;\frac{323.5-312.9-(-15+7.5+10)}{312.9+\lbrack(-15)\times0.742+7.5\times0.613+10\times0.387\rbrack}=\;0.0261\;=\;2.61\%

如题，不太理解为何只有分母需要cash flow*weight factor而分子不用呢？

添加评论
1 个答案

伯恩_品职助教 · 2023年04月24日

嗨，努力学习的PZer你好：


分子为什么要调权重呢？分母变化是变化的收益率，分子是实打实的的收益，收益是多少就是多少！不会因为进入portfolio的早晚就会有变化！打个比方，1月1日净值有1000万，1月15日新增700万，1月31日净值是2000万，收益怎么算？2000-700-1000=300万对吧，300万的收益是多少就是多少！总不能因为进入资金晚了，就要打折处理吧，给投资者说因为是月中旬进入的，所以700万要打折处理，你的700万这里只能算350万？？？？？！！！！！！

----------------------------------------------
努力的时光都是限量版，加油！

  • 1

    回答

  • 0

    关注

  • 292

    浏览
相关问题

题干错误 没有给出这三个月组合的return，没办法计算。只能找到权重。其次这个问题计算composite return的第一项没有这种说法，这个是计算组合收益的

2024-10-16 10:33 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2022010501000005 问题如下 A Europeequity composite contains three portfolios whose cash flow weighting factors are follows.A Calculate the returns of Portfolio Portfolio anPortfolio C for the month of August using Mofieetz formula.B Calculate the August composite return asset-weighting the inviportfolio returns using beginning-of- periovalues.C Calculate the August composite return asset- weighting the inviportfolio returns using a methothreflects both beginning-of-periovalues anexterncash flows. A Portfolio returns:rA=85.3−74.9−7.574.9+（7.5×0.613）=2.979.5=0.0365=3.65%r_A=\frac{85.3-74.9-7.5}{74.9+（7.5\times0.613）}=\frac{2.9}{79.5}=0.0365=3.65\%rA​=74.9+（7.5×0.613）85.3−74.9−7.5​=79.52.9​=0.0365=3.65%rB=109.8−127.6−(−15)−(−5)127.6+（−15×0.742）+(−5×0.387）=2.2114.535=0.0192=1.92%r_B=\frac{109.8-127.6-(-15)-(-5)}{127.6+（-15\times0.742）+(-5\times0.387）}=\frac{2.2}{114.535}=0.0192=1.92\%rB​=127.6+（−15×0.742）+(−5×0.387）109.8−127.6−(−15)−(−5)​=114.5352.2​=0.0192=1.92%rC=128.4−110.4−15110.4+（15×0.387）=3116.205=0.0258=2.58%r_C=\frac{128.4-110.4-15}{110.4+（15\times0.387）}=\frac3{116.205}=0.0258=2.58\%rC​=110.4+（15×0.387）128.4−110.4−15​=116.2053​=0.0258=2.58% B To calculate the composite return baseon beginning assets, first termine the percentage of beginning composite assets representeeaportfolio; then termine the weighteaverage return for the month: Beginning composite assets = 74.9 + 127.6 + 110.4 = 312.9Portfolio A = 74.9/312.9 = 0.239 = 23.9%Portfolio B = 127.6/312.9 = 0.408 = 40.8%Portfolio C = 110.4/312.9 = 0.353 = 35.3%rComp=  (0.0365  ×  0.239)  +  (0.0192  ×  0.408)  +  (0.0258  ×  0.353)=  0.0257  =  2.57%r_{Comp}=\;(0.0365\;\times\;0.239)\;+\;(0.0192\;\times\;0.408)\;+\;(0.0258\;\times\;0.353)=\;0.0257\;=\;2.57\%rComp​=(0.0365×0.239)+(0.0192×0.408)+(0.0258×0.353)=0.0257=2.57%C To calculate the composite return baseon beginning assets plus cash flows, first use the nominator of the Mofieetz formula to termine the percentage of totbeginning assets plus weightecash flows representeeaportfolio, anthen calculate the weighteaverage return: Beginning composite assets + Weightecash flows = [74.9 + (7.5 × 0.613)] + [127.6 + (−15 × 0.742) + (−5 × 0.387)] + [110.4 + (15 × 0.387)] = 79.5 + 114.535 + 116.205 = 310.24Portfolio A = 79.5/310.24 = 0.256 = 25.6%Portfolio B = 114.535/310.24 = 0.369 = 36.9% Portfolio C = 116.205/310.24 = 0.375 = 37.5%rComp  =  (0.0365  ×  0.256)  +  (0.0192  ×  0.369)  +  (0.0258  ×  0.375)    =  0.0261  =  2.61%r_{Comp}\;=\;(0.0365\;\times\;0.256)\;+\;(0.0192\;\times\;0.369)\;+\;(0.0258\;\times\;0.375)\;\;=\;0.0261\;=\;2.61\%rComp​=(0.0365×0.256)+(0.0192×0.369)+(0.0258×0.375)=0.0261=2.61%The Aggregate Return methois calculatesumming beginning assets anintrperioexterncash flows, treating the entire composite though it were a single portfolio anthen computing the return rectly with the Mofieetz formula.rComp  =  323.5−312.9−(−15+7.5+10)312.9+[(−15)×0.742+7.5×0.613+10×0.387]=  0.0261  =  2.61%r_{Comp}\;=\;\frac{323.5-312.9-(-15+7.5+10)}{312.9+\lbrack(-15)\times0.742+7.5\times0.613+10\times0.387\rbrack}=\;0.0261\;=\;2.61\%rComp​=312.9+[(−15)×0.742+7.5×0.613+10×0.387]323.5−312.9−(−15+7.5+10)​=0.0261=2.61% 请问这题，在计算B,C的时候，为什么可以直接带入A的结果？A用的是mofieetz methoportfolio return。B和C不是应该用TWR 算portfolio return么？谢谢

2024-10-15 07:06 2 · 回答

NO.PZ2022010501000005 问题如下 A Europeequity composite contains three portfolios whose cash flow weighting factors are follows.A Calculate the returns of Portfolio Portfolio anPortfolio C for the month of August using Mofieetz formula.B Calculate the August composite return asset-weighting the inviportfolio returns using beginning-of- periovalues.C Calculate the August composite return asset- weighting the inviportfolio returns using a methothreflects both beginning-of-periovalues anexterncash flows. A Portfolio returns:rA=85.3−74.9−7.574.9+（7.5×0.613）=2.979.5=0.0365=3.65%r_A=\frac{85.3-74.9-7.5}{74.9+（7.5\times0.613）}=\frac{2.9}{79.5}=0.0365=3.65\%rA​=74.9+（7.5×0.613）85.3−74.9−7.5​=79.52.9​=0.0365=3.65%rB=109.8−127.6−(−15)−(−5)127.6+（−15×0.742）+(−5×0.387）=2.2114.535=0.0192=1.92%r_B=\frac{109.8-127.6-(-15)-(-5)}{127.6+（-15\times0.742）+(-5\times0.387）}=\frac{2.2}{114.535}=0.0192=1.92\%rB​=127.6+（−15×0.742）+(−5×0.387）109.8−127.6−(−15)−(−5)​=114.5352.2​=0.0192=1.92%rC=128.4−110.4−15110.4+（15×0.387）=3116.205=0.0258=2.58%r_C=\frac{128.4-110.4-15}{110.4+（15\times0.387）}=\frac3{116.205}=0.0258=2.58\%rC​=110.4+（15×0.387）128.4−110.4−15​=116.2053​=0.0258=2.58% B To calculate the composite return baseon beginning assets, first termine the percentage of beginning composite assets representeeaportfolio; then termine the weighteaverage return for the month: Beginning composite assets = 74.9 + 127.6 + 110.4 = 312.9Portfolio A = 74.9/312.9 = 0.239 = 23.9%Portfolio B = 127.6/312.9 = 0.408 = 40.8%Portfolio C = 110.4/312.9 = 0.353 = 35.3%rComp=  (0.0365  ×  0.239)  +  (0.0192  ×  0.408)  +  (0.0258  ×  0.353)=  0.0257  =  2.57%r_{Comp}=\;(0.0365\;\times\;0.239)\;+\;(0.0192\;\times\;0.408)\;+\;(0.0258\;\times\;0.353)=\;0.0257\;=\;2.57\%rComp​=(0.0365×0.239)+(0.0192×0.408)+(0.0258×0.353)=0.0257=2.57%C To calculate the composite return baseon beginning assets plus cash flows, first use the nominator of the Mofieetz formula to termine the percentage of totbeginning assets plus weightecash flows representeeaportfolio, anthen calculate the weighteaverage return: Beginning composite assets + Weightecash flows = [74.9 + (7.5 × 0.613)] + [127.6 + (−15 × 0.742) + (−5 × 0.387)] + [110.4 + (15 × 0.387)] = 79.5 + 114.535 + 116.205 = 310.24Portfolio A = 79.5/310.24 = 0.256 = 25.6%Portfolio B = 114.535/310.24 = 0.369 = 36.9% Portfolio C = 116.205/310.24 = 0.375 = 37.5%rComp  =  (0.0365  ×  0.256)  +  (0.0192  ×  0.369)  +  (0.0258  ×  0.375)    =  0.0261  =  2.61%r_{Comp}\;=\;(0.0365\;\times\;0.256)\;+\;(0.0192\;\times\;0.369)\;+\;(0.0258\;\times\;0.375)\;\;=\;0.0261\;=\;2.61\%rComp​=(0.0365×0.256)+(0.0192×0.369)+(0.0258×0.375)=0.0261=2.61%The Aggregate Return methois calculatesumming beginning assets anintrperioexterncash flows, treating the entire composite though it were a single portfolio anthen computing the return rectly with the Mofieetz formula.rComp  =  323.5−312.9−(−15+7.5+10)312.9+[(−15)×0.742+7.5×0.613+10×0.387]=  0.0261  =  2.61%r_{Comp}\;=\;\frac{323.5-312.9-(-15+7.5+10)}{312.9+\lbrack(-15)\times0.742+7.5\times0.613+10\times0.387\rbrack}=\;0.0261\;=\;2.61\%rComp​=312.9+[(−15)×0.742+7.5×0.613+10×0.387]323.5−312.9−(−15+7.5+10)​=0.0261=2.61% 对于B和C问，讲义中是基于TWR来算这些回报率的，但是这里用的是mofieetz的方法，考试时，应该基于什么回报率哦？

2024-07-26 21:11 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2022010501000005 问题如下 A Europeequity composite contains three portfolios whose cash flow weighting factors are follows.A Calculate the returns of Portfolio Portfolio anPortfolio C for the month of August using Mofieetz formula.B Calculate the August composite return asset-weighting the inviportfolio returns using beginning-of- periovalues.C Calculate the August composite return asset- weighting the inviportfolio returns using a methothreflects both beginning-of-periovalues anexterncash flows. A Portfolio returns:rA=85.3−74.9−7.574.9+（7.5×0.613）=2.979.5=0.0365=3.65%r_A=\frac{85.3-74.9-7.5}{74.9+（7.5\times0.613）}=\frac{2.9}{79.5}=0.0365=3.65\%rA​=74.9+（7.5×0.613）85.3−74.9−7.5​=79.52.9​=0.0365=3.65%rB=109.8−127.6−(−15)−(−5)127.6+（−15×0.742）+(−5×0.387）=2.2114.535=0.0192=1.92%r_B=\frac{109.8-127.6-(-15)-(-5)}{127.6+（-15\times0.742）+(-5\times0.387）}=\frac{2.2}{114.535}=0.0192=1.92\%rB​=127.6+（−15×0.742）+(−5×0.387）109.8−127.6−(−15)−(−5)​=114.5352.2​=0.0192=1.92%rC=128.4−110.4−15110.4+（15×0.387）=3116.205=0.0258=2.58%r_C=\frac{128.4-110.4-15}{110.4+（15\times0.387）}=\frac3{116.205}=0.0258=2.58\%rC​=110.4+（15×0.387）128.4−110.4−15​=116.2053​=0.0258=2.58% B To calculate the composite return baseon beginning assets, first termine the percentage of beginning composite assets representeeaportfolio; then termine the weighteaverage return for the month: Beginning composite assets = 74.9 + 127.6 + 110.4 = 312.9Portfolio A = 74.9/312.9 = 0.239 = 23.9%Portfolio B = 127.6/312.9 = 0.408 = 40.8%Portfolio C = 110.4/312.9 = 0.353 = 35.3%rComp=  (0.0365  ×  0.239)  +  (0.0192  ×  0.408)  +  (0.0258  ×  0.353)=  0.0257  =  2.57%r_{Comp}=\;(0.0365\;\times\;0.239)\;+\;(0.0192\;\times\;0.408)\;+\;(0.0258\;\times\;0.353)=\;0.0257\;=\;2.57\%rComp​=(0.0365×0.239)+(0.0192×0.408)+(0.0258×0.353)=0.0257=2.57%C To calculate the composite return baseon beginning assets plus cash flows, first use the nominator of the Mofieetz formula to termine the percentage of totbeginning assets plus weightecash flows representeeaportfolio, anthen calculate the weighteaverage return: Beginning composite assets + Weightecash flows = [74.9 + (7.5 × 0.613)] + [127.6 + (−15 × 0.742) + (−5 × 0.387)] + [110.4 + (15 × 0.387)] = 79.5 + 114.535 + 116.205 = 310.24Portfolio A = 79.5/310.24 = 0.256 = 25.6%Portfolio B = 114.535/310.24 = 0.369 = 36.9% Portfolio C = 116.205/310.24 = 0.375 = 37.5%rComp  =  (0.0365  ×  0.256)  +  (0.0192  ×  0.369)  +  (0.0258  ×  0.375)    =  0.0261  =  2.61%r_{Comp}\;=\;(0.0365\;\times\;0.256)\;+\;(0.0192\;\times\;0.369)\;+\;(0.0258\;\times\;0.375)\;\;=\;0.0261\;=\;2.61\%rComp​=(0.0365×0.256)+(0.0192×0.369)+(0.0258×0.375)=0.0261=2.61%The Aggregate Return methois calculatesumming beginning assets anintrperioexterncash flows, treating the entire composite though it were a single portfolio anthen computing the return rectly with the Mofieetz formula.rComp  =  323.5−312.9−(−15+7.5+10)312.9+[(−15)×0.742+7.5×0.613+10×0.387]=  0.0261  =  2.61%r_{Comp}\;=\;\frac{323.5-312.9-(-15+7.5+10)}{312.9+\lbrack(-15)\times0.742+7.5\times0.613+10\times0.387\rbrack}=\;0.0261\;=\;2.61\%rComp​=312.9+[(−15)×0.742+7.5×0.613+10×0.387]323.5−312.9−(−15+7.5+10)​=0.0261=2.61% 老师，第三问，答案是不是写错了？我算是3.48%。有一笔正负号答案好像写错了。

2024-06-29 21:31 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2022010501000005 问题如下 A Europeequity composite contains three portfolios whose cash flow weighting factors are follows.A Calculate the returns of Portfolio Portfolio anPortfolio C for the month of August using Mofieetz formula.B Calculate the August composite return asset-weighting the inviportfolio returns using beginning-of- periovalues.C Calculate the August composite return asset- weighting the inviportfolio returns using a methothreflects both beginning-of-periovalues anexterncash flows. A Portfolio returns:rA=85.3−74.9−7.574.9+（7.5×0.613）=2.979.5=0.0365=3.65%r_A=\frac{85.3-74.9-7.5}{74.9+（7.5\times0.613）}=\frac{2.9}{79.5}=0.0365=3.65\%rA​=74.9+（7.5×0.613）85.3−74.9−7.5​=79.52.9​=0.0365=3.65%rB=109.8−127.6−(−15)−(−5)127.6+（−15×0.742）+(−5×0.387）=2.2114.535=0.0192=1.92%r_B=\frac{109.8-127.6-(-15)-(-5)}{127.6+（-15\times0.742）+(-5\times0.387）}=\frac{2.2}{114.535}=0.0192=1.92\%rB​=127.6+（−15×0.742）+(−5×0.387）109.8−127.6−(−15)−(−5)​=114.5352.2​=0.0192=1.92%rC=128.4−110.4−15110.4+（15×0.387）=3116.205=0.0258=2.58%r_C=\frac{128.4-110.4-15}{110.4+（15\times0.387）}=\frac3{116.205}=0.0258=2.58\%rC​=110.4+（15×0.387）128.4−110.4−15​=116.2053​=0.0258=2.58% B To calculate the composite return baseon beginning assets, first termine the percentage of beginning composite assets representeeaportfolio; then termine the weighteaverage return for the month: Beginning composite assets = 74.9 + 127.6 + 110.4 = 312.9Portfolio A = 74.9/312.9 = 0.239 = 23.9%Portfolio B = 127.6/312.9 = 0.408 = 40.8%Portfolio C = 110.4/312.9 = 0.353 = 35.3%rComp=  (0.0365  ×  0.239)  +  (0.0192  ×  0.408)  +  (0.0258  ×  0.353)=  0.0257  =  2.57%r_{Comp}=\;(0.0365\;\times\;0.239)\;+\;(0.0192\;\times\;0.408)\;+\;(0.0258\;\times\;0.353)=\;0.0257\;=\;2.57\%rComp​=(0.0365×0.239)+(0.0192×0.408)+(0.0258×0.353)=0.0257=2.57%C To calculate the composite return baseon beginning assets plus cash flows, first use the nominator of the Mofieetz formula to termine the percentage of totbeginning assets plus weightecash flows representeeaportfolio, anthen calculate the weighteaverage return: Beginning composite assets + Weightecash flows = [74.9 + (7.5 × 0.613)] + [127.6 + (−15 × 0.742) + (−5 × 0.387)] + [110.4 + (15 × 0.387)] = 79.5 + 114.535 + 116.205 = 310.24Portfolio A = 79.5/310.24 = 0.256 = 25.6%Portfolio B = 114.535/310.24 = 0.369 = 36.9% Portfolio C = 116.205/310.24 = 0.375 = 37.5%rComp  =  (0.0365  ×  0.256)  +  (0.0192  ×  0.369)  +  (0.0258  ×  0.375)    =  0.0261  =  2.61%r_{Comp}\;=\;(0.0365\;\times\;0.256)\;+\;(0.0192\;\times\;0.369)\;+\;(0.0258\;\times\;0.375)\;\;=\;0.0261\;=\;2.61\%rComp​=(0.0365×0.256)+(0.0192×0.369)+(0.0258×0.375)=0.0261=2.61%The Aggregate Return methois calculatesumming beginning assets anintrperioexterncash flows, treating the entire composite though it were a single portfolio anthen computing the return rectly with the Mofieetz formula.rComp  =  323.5−312.9−(−15+7.5+10)312.9+[(−15)×0.742+7.5×0.613+10×0.387]=  0.0261  =  2.61%r_{Comp}\;=\;\frac{323.5-312.9-(-15+7.5+10)}{312.9+\lbrack(-15)\times0.742+7.5\times0.613+10\times0.387\rbrack}=\;0.0261\;=\;2.61\%rComp​=312.9+[(−15)×0.742+7.5×0.613+10×0.387]323.5−312.9−(−15+7.5+10)​=0.0261=2.61% 如题。

2024-05-18 15:00 2 · 回答