开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

婷 · 2022年09月20日

strategy1和2都能获利,为什么2是错的

* 问题详情,请 查看题干

NO.PZ202208100100000201

问题如下:

Are the strategies suggested by Dufu for Kadakia most likely correct?

选项:

A.

Yes, both strategies are correct.

B.

No, Strategy 1 is incorrect.

C.

No, Strategy 2 is incorrect.

解释:

Solution

C is correct. Strategy 1 is correct and Strategy 2 is incorrect. Given Kadakia’s expectations, the correct option strategy is a bear spread using calls. The bear spread can be implemented using call options or put options. In either case, it involves the purchase of the higher strike option and the sale of the lower strike option. Kadakia, however, has indicated that she would like to avoid a cash outlay. Given this constraint, the appropriate option strategy is to purchase November 120 call options and sell November 115 call options because doing so will result in an initial cash inflow of $5.40 – $2.70 = $2.70. Using put options would result in an initial cash outflow of $2.37 and a maximum profit of $2.63, which is less than the $2.70 maximum profit for the bear spread using calls. Net $2.63 if the stock falls below 115.

A is incorrect. Strategy 2 is incorrect because using put options would result in an initial cash outflow of $2.37.

B is incorrect. Strategy 1 is correct.

strategy1和2都能获利,题目没说要获利最大化,只是说成本最小,strategy2的成本不是更小?

1 个答案

Hertz_品职助教 · 2022年09月20日

嗨,努力学习的PZer你好:


同学你好

策略2相比于策略1并没有成本更小,是策略1的成本更小。

虽然像策略2中使用put option来构建也是可以的。但是可以计算到最后的成本是2.37美元(构建策略2,买put花掉了5.22美元,卖put收到了2.85美元,有一个净支出为2.37美元。)。

但是构建策略1呢,买call花掉了2.7美元;卖call收到了5.4美元,有一个净收入为2.7美元。

因此可以看到相比于策略2,策略1明显是更有优势的呀,所以策略1是合适的哈。

----------------------------------------------
努力的时光都是限量版,加油!

  • 1

    回答
  • 1

    关注
  • 574

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ202208100100000201 问题如下 Are the strategies suggestefu for Kakia most likely correct? A.Yes, both strategies are correct. B.No, Strategy 1 is incorrect. C.No, Strategy 2 is incorrect. SolutionC is correct. Strategy 1 is correanStrategy 2 is incorrect. Given Kakia’s expectations, the correoption strategy is a bespreusing calls. The besprecimplementeusing call options or put options. In either case, it involves the purchase of the higher strike option anthe sale of the lower strike option. Kakihowever, hincatethshe woullike to avoia cash outlay. Given this constraint, the appropriate option strategy is to purchase November 120 call options ansell November 115 call options because ing so will result in initicash inflow of $5.40 – $2.70 = $2.70. Using put options woulresult in initicash outflow of $2.37 ana maximum profit of $2.63, whiis less ththe $2.70 maximum profit for the bespreusing calls. Net $2.63 if the stofalls below 115.A is incorrect. Strategy 2 is incorrebecause using put options woulresult in initicash outflow of $2.37.B is incorrect. Strategy 1 is correct.中文解析本题考察的是besprea题干第二段说Kakia预计XYZ公司的股价在下个月将大幅下跌。Kakia希望利用期权从股价下跌中获利,但如果预期的股价下跌没有实现,他也希望限制损失。Kakia还表示,她希望将建立期权头寸的成本降至最低。根据Kakia的预测,结合策略1和策略2中的策略,可知本题考察的是besprea其中策略1是使用call option来构建的becall sprea策略2是使用put option来构建的beput option。但是二者两个策略的成本不同构建策略1,买call花掉了2.7美元;卖call收到了5.4美元,有一个净收入为2.7美元;构建策略2,买put花掉了5.22美元,卖put收到了2.85美元,有一个净支出为2.37美元。由于Kakia希望将成本降至最低,因此策略1是合适的。 有点不太确定, 当是bearish market,股价都在下降,那么为什么bearish call可以赚钱?bearish call = Long x高的 call + short x低的call。本身这个头寸是一个net cash inflow 也就是一个cret sprea所以我们就用short x 低的call 赚一个期权费?同样的逻辑 当是bullish market,股价再上涨,那么为什么 bullish put可以赚钱?Bullihs put = Long x 低的 put + short x 高的 put, net cahs inflow 也是一个cret sprea所以我们赚钱的来源是short x高的put 这个头寸中的期权费?

2024-07-04 10:49 1 · 回答

NO.PZ202208100100000201 问题如下 Are the strategies suggestefu for Kakia most likely correct? A.Yes, both strategies are correct. B.No, Strategy 1 is incorrect. C.No, Strategy 2 is incorrect. SolutionC is correct. Strategy 1 is correanStrategy 2 is incorrect. Given Kakia’s expectations, the correoption strategy is a bespreusing calls. The besprecimplementeusing call options or put options. In either case, it involves the purchase of the higher strike option anthe sale of the lower strike option. Kakihowever, hincatethshe woullike to avoia cash outlay. Given this constraint, the appropriate option strategy is to purchase November 120 call options ansell November 115 call options because ing so will result in initicash inflow of $5.40 – $2.70 = $2.70. Using put options woulresult in initicash outflow of $2.37 ana maximum profit of $2.63, whiis less ththe $2.70 maximum profit for the bespreusing calls. Net $2.63 if the stofalls below 115.A is incorrect. Strategy 2 is incorrebecause using put options woulresult in initicash outflow of $2.37.B is incorrect. Strategy 1 is correct.中文解析本题考察的是besprea题干第二段说Kakia预计XYZ公司的股价在下个月将大幅下跌。Kakia希望利用期权从股价下跌中获利,但如果预期的股价下跌没有实现,他也希望限制损失。Kakia还表示,她希望将建立期权头寸的成本降至最低。根据Kakia的预测,结合策略1和策略2中的策略,可知本题考察的是besprea其中策略1是使用call option来构建的becall sprea策略2是使用put option来构建的beput option。但是二者两个策略的成本不同构建策略1,买call花掉了2.7美元;卖call收到了5.4美元,有一个净收入为2.7美元;构建策略2,买put花掉了5.22美元,卖put收到了2.85美元,有一个净支出为2.37美元。由于Kakia希望将成本降至最低,因此策略1是合适的。 expebearish market,不是应该用strategy 2?

2024-03-24 08:08 1 · 回答

NO.PZ202208100100000201 问题如下 Are the strategies suggestefu for Kakia most likely correct? A.Yes, both strategies are correct. B.No, Strategy 1 is incorrect. C.No, Strategy 2 is incorrect. SolutionC is correct. Strategy 1 is correanStrategy 2 is incorrect. Given Kakia’s expectations, the correoption strategy is a bespreusing calls. The besprecimplementeusing call options or put options. In either case, it involves the purchase of the higher strike option anthe sale of the lower strike option. Kakihowever, hincatethshe woullike to avoia cash outlay. Given this constraint, the appropriate option strategy is to purchase November 120 call options ansell November 115 call options because ing so will result in initicash inflow of $5.40 – $2.70 = $2.70. Using put options woulresult in initicash outflow of $2.37 ana maximum profit of $2.63, whiis less ththe $2.70 maximum profit for the bespreusing calls. Net $2.63 if the stofalls below 115.A is incorrect. Strategy 2 is incorrebecause using put options woulresult in initicash outflow of $2.37.B is incorrect. Strategy 1 is correct.中文解析本题考察的是besprea题干第二段说Kakia预计XYZ公司的股价在下个月将大幅下跌。Kakia希望利用期权从股价下跌中获利,但如果预期的股价下跌没有实现,他也希望限制损失。Kakia还表示,她希望将建立期权头寸的成本降至最低。根据Kakia的预测,结合策略1和策略2中的策略,可知本题考察的是besprea其中策略1是使用call option来构建的becall sprea策略2是使用put option来构建的beput option。但是二者两个策略的成本不同构建策略1,买call花掉了2.7美元;卖call收到了5.4美元,有一个净收入为2.7美元;构建策略2,买put花掉了5.22美元,卖put收到了2.85美元,有一个净支出为2.37美元。由于Kakia希望将成本降至最低,因此策略1是合适的。 这题为什么不考虑当前价格是117.43呢?只考虑期初的净期权费?strategy1 short call 已经要有赔付给对手方了strategy 2 至少long put已经就有收益了呀

2024-02-05 11:12 1 · 回答

NO.PZ202208100100000201问题如下 Are the strategies suggestefu for Kakia most likely correct? A.Yes, both strategies are correct.B.No, Strategy 1 is incorrect.C.No, Strategy 2 is incorrect. SolutionC is correct. Strategy 1 is correanStrategy 2 is incorrect. Given Kakia’s expectations, the correoption strategy is a bespreusing calls. The besprecimplementeusing call options or put options. In either case, it involves the purchase of the higher strike option anthe sale of the lower strike option. Kakihowever, hincatethshe woullike to avoia cash outlay. Given this constraint, the appropriate option strategy is to purchase November 120 call options ansell November 115 call options because ing so will result in initicash inflow of $5.40 – $2.70 = $2.70. Using put options woulresult in initicash outflow of $2.37 ana maximum profit of $2.63, whiis less ththe $2.70 maximum profit for the bespreusing calls. Net $2.63 if the stofalls below 115.A is incorrect. Strategy 2 is incorrebecause using put options woulresult in initicash outflow of $2.37.B is incorrect. Strategy 1 is correct.中文解析本题考察的是besprea题干第二段说Kakia预计XYZ公司的股价在下个月将大幅下跌。Kakia希望利用期权从股价下跌中获利,但如果预期的股价下跌没有实现,他也希望限制损失。Kakia还表示,她希望将建立期权头寸的成本降至最低。根据Kakia的预测,结合策略1和策略2中的策略,可知本题考察的是besprea其中策略1是使用call option来构建的becall sprea策略2是使用put option来构建的beput option。但是二者两个策略的成本不同构建策略1,买call花掉了2.7美元;卖call收到了5.4美元,有一个净收入为2.7美元;构建策略2,买put花掉了5.22美元,卖put收到了2.85美元,有一个净支出为2.37美元。由于Kakia希望将成本降至最低,因此策略1是合适的。 老师,预期股票价格不是下跌吗,为什么要买call 呢

2023-12-07 10:03 1 · 回答

NO.PZ202208100100000201 问题如下 Are the strategies suggestefu for Kakia most likely correct? A.Yes, both strategies are correct. B.No, Strategy 1 is incorrect. C.No, Strategy 2 is incorrect. SolutionC is correct. Strategy 1 is correanStrategy 2 is incorrect. Given Kakia’s expectations, the correoption strategy is a bespreusing calls. The besprecimplementeusing call options or put options. In either case, it involves the purchase of the higher strike option anthe sale of the lower strike option. Kakihowever, hincatethshe woullike to avoia cash outlay. Given this constraint, the appropriate option strategy is to purchase November 120 call options ansell November 115 call options because ing so will result in initicash inflow of $5.40 – $2.70 = $2.70. Using put options woulresult in initicash outflow of $2.37 ana maximum profit of $2.63, whiis less ththe $2.70 maximum profit for the bespreusing calls. Net $2.63 if the stofalls below 115.A is incorrect. Strategy 2 is incorrebecause using put options woulresult in initicash outflow of $2.37.B is incorrect. Strategy 1 is correct. 首先,题目要求1.利用价格下降获得profit; 2. 降低成本。所以两个策略都属于besprea满足要求啊,第二个策略怎么就不行?

2022-11-17 08:09 1 · 回答