开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

石头鱼170 · 2018年04月04日

请问一个三级TMR的题

He states that VWAP attempts to measure the price benchmark for a trade with greater precision than other measures. Furthermore, Larkin asserts that VWAP is not affected by market impact implicit costs.And, he concludes, VWAP’s greatest contribution is that it provides an objective measure of missed trade opportunity costs.


Larkin’s description of VWAP is most accurate with respect to:

1.opportunity cost

2.    market impact.

3.    price benchmarks.


Solution

C is correct. VWAP attempts to measure the price benchmark for a trade with greater precision than other measures. Missed trade opportunity costs are difficult to measure, and VWAP does little to resolve those difficulties. Market impact costs are similarly difficult to measure.

A is incorrect because market impact costs are difficult to measure.

B is incorrect because missed trade opportunity costs are difficult to measure, and VWAP does little to resolve those difficulties.

我的问题:老师 我认为描述中VWAP比其他作为基准更准确这个说法不对,忽略了很多成本;不受隐性成本影响这个说法正确;提供衡量未成交成本的这个说法肯定不对。可否请老师讲解一下正确答案?谢谢!

1 个答案
已采纳答案

竹子 · 2018年04月04日

首先,VWAP作为一个benchmark本来就是用来衡量隐性成本的,与它同样可以作为衡量隐性成本的benchmark还有开盘价与收盘价。

既然VWAP可以衡量隐性成本,那它当然受隐性成本的影响。虽然VWAP作为benchmark有很多缺点,但与收盘价与开盘价比,还是靠谱一些的。

但是,虽然vwap可以衡量隐性成本,但它衡量不了具体的每种隐性成本有多少,比如market impact有多少,opportunity cost有多少,这个只有implenmentation shortfall 才可以

  • 1

    回答
  • 0

    关注
  • 348

    浏览
相关问题